Darwin plagiarizes to Pierre Tremaux?


by Salia Narcovi
Tags: allopatric, evolution, speciation, tremaux
Salia Narcovi
Salia Narcovi is offline
#1
Sep28-08, 09:32 AM
P: 1
Darwin plagiarizes to Pierre Tremaux?


I leave you the link to scientific paper that it affirms that to the idea of allopatric speciation borrow of a book of Pierre Tremaux.


Trémaux on species: A theory of allopatric speciation (and punctuated equilibrium) before Wagner

http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/archive/00003806/


Tremaux's Book :“Origine et transformations de l’homme et des autres êtres, 1865″

http://fon.gs/tremaux-book-google/
Phys.Org News Partner Biology news on Phys.org
Bulletproof nuclei? Stem cells exhibit unusual absorption property
Computational method dramatically speeds up estimates of gene expression
Free the seed: OSSI nurtures growing plants without patent barriers
Mike H
Mike H is offline
#2
Sep28-08, 10:26 AM
P: 464
Interesting paper, I don't know enough about the history of science to conclusively comment, although the paper doesn't argue for anything as definitive. The 1866 revision of Origin of Species came out a year after Tremaux's book in 1865 - while Darwin had a copy of it in his library, and apparently read it (based on a notation found in his copy), I don't see any information on *when* he acquired the book. Maybe he picked up a copy in 1867 after having been referred to it, and he didn't find anything new of interest.

Of course, it seems that Wagner and Gould/Eldridge also could have been used for the title of this post, but that's a separate discussion, I'd figure.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Darwin vs. evolution Biology 20
SNL Darwin cartoon General Discussion 3
About Darwin Biology 3
Darwin or not? Social Sciences 29
Charles Darwin General Discussion 4