How Can I Build a Small Electromagnetic Train for a Model Setup?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers on building a small electromagnetic train model, exploring various designs and mechanisms for propulsion and levitation. Participants express interest in creating a setup that fits within a limited space, specifically a circular track no larger than 12 inches in diameter. The conversation includes inquiries about power requirements, computing needs, and the feasibility of different magnetic configurations.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests a simple approach using a rotating disc with a magnet to drag the train around a circular track.
  • Another participant questions the definition of "electromagnetic train," seeking clarification on whether it refers to a traditional electric train, a magnet-powered train, or a magnetic levitation (maglev) train.
  • There are inquiries about how to achieve levitation for the train, with one participant proposing the use of magnets arranged in a circular configuration to create repulsive forces.
  • A suggestion is made to use a series of electromagnets arranged in an asterisk shape to create a magnetic drive system, with the goal of moving an object above the magnets as they are energized and de-energized.
  • Another participant proposes a design involving a cylindrical tube with a neodymium magnet and coils wound around it to propel a train car along a track.
  • Some participants emphasize the importance of understanding electricity and circuits when working with electromagnets.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various ideas and approaches, but there is no consensus on a single method for building the electromagnetic train. Multiple competing views and designs are presented, indicating an unresolved discussion.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention the need for further understanding of electromagnetism, electricity, and motor design, suggesting that the discussion may require foundational knowledge in these areas. There are also references to the time investment needed to learn about the technologies involved.

JAFO
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Ok , here's the deal , i would like to build a small electromagnetic train ... ( not really a train , but you know what i mean... no bigger than an "N" scale train , if you know anything about model trains) i just want a basic simple setup that goes in a circle ... no bigger than a dinner plate, let's say 12 inches in diameter. I can't seem to find a thing about it on the internet , and don't have a clue where to begin ... don't tell me to go to the local library or book store because there isn't a decent one within 100 miles of me. I suck at math , i don't know a thing about magnets , but i can learn. Any input on doing this would be greatly appreciated. Some of the things i need to know ... how much power might something that small need... what kind of computing power would i need to run these electromagnets (to run the sensors and transfer of the poles)... and where in he** would i find these items?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Jafo:
Math is for things you understand.Simple approach: Put train on circular track with magnet under locomotive. Under the table, a circular disc of plywood with a magnet glued on. As the disk rotates, it drags the locomotive around the track. What? Too simple? You want an electromagnetic drive? In that case, your "track" has to be a linear motor. That is, windings same as on a motor only laid out in a line instead of a (rotating) cylinder. There are 1000s of books on motors, motor design, etc. Allow a couple years to get up to speed. Now, if you want to support the train magnetically, or electromagnetically, that is step 2. Not that many books but the technology is getting fairly well established. I would allow a year or two more to get up to speed on that. Since you will be winding a lot of electromagnets, i guess it would be a good idea to get some experience there also. Get some old relays (or new ones if you prefer). Operate them and get familiar with how they operate. Now take them apart and see how the coils are wound. Try winding a coil with a different wire size, and see how the relay operates. This is also a whole field of technology.
Re Books: There is no KNOWLEDGE in books. There are WORDS in books. Knowledge was in the person that wrote the books. But the process is not basically a reversible process. There are people who do not understand this. Watch out for them.
I almost forgot: if you will be working with electromagnets, maybe you should learn something about electricity, circuits, etc.
Reminds me of the story aboout the little boy that went to the hardware store to buy a switch. He said "I want a switch that will open my garage door and turn on the light".
The clerk asked "do you have the door operator and everything else?" The kid said "Whats that?
Modern hardware design can deceive people into thinking that something very complex is very simple- just a switch. End of lecture
Freddie
 
Just to clarrify;

When you say "electromagnetic train", do you mean a regular electric train, a train powered by a magnet, or a magnetic levitation (maglev) train?
 
LURCH said:
Just to clarrify;

When you say "electromagnetic train", do you mean a regular electric train, a train powered by a magnet, or a magnetic levitation (maglev) train?

yes powered by magnet how do you make it move?
:eek: :zzz:
 
please can anyone tell me how to get the train to stay in levitate
i would really like to know?
 
could one build a circular track. BUild small walls with N magnets on the outside and S mag. on the inside of the circle (both facing in towards the track. put magnets on the sides of the train opposite of the walls. And put a magnet on the bottom of the train which repels one placed underneath of the track that rotates like Freddie suggested?.. may be a little bulky but you could refine it as u like.

...

Math is for things you understand.Simple approach: Put train on circular track with magnet under locomotive. Under the table, a circular disc of plywood with a magnet glued on. As the disk rotates, it drags the locomotive around the track. What? Too simple? You want an electromagnetic drive? In that case, your "track" has to be a linear motor. That is, windings same as on a motor only laid out in a line instead of a (rotating) cylinder. There are 1000s of books on motors, motor design, etc. Allow a couple years to get up to speed. Now, if you want to support the train magnetically, or electromagnetically, that is step 2. Not that many books but the technology is getting fairly well established. I would allow a year or two more to get up to speed on that. Since you will be winding a lot of electromagnets, i guess it would be a good idea to get some experience there also. Get some old relays (or new ones if you prefer). Operate them and get familiar with how they operate. Now take them apart and see how the coils are wound. Try winding a coil with a different wire size, and see how the relay operates. This is also a whole field of technology.
Re Books: There is no KNOWLEDGE in books. There are WORDS in books. Knowledge was in the person that wrote the books. But the process is not basically a reversible process. There are people who do not understand this. Watch out for them.
I almost forgot: if you will be working with electromagnets, maybe you should learn something about electricity, circuits, etc.
Reminds me of the story aboout the little boy that went to the hardware store to buy a switch. He said "I want a switch that will open my garage door and turn on the light".
The clerk asked "do you have the door operator and everything else?" The kid said "Whats that?
Modern hardware design can deceive people into thinking that something very complex is very simple- just a switch. End of lecture
Freddie
 
Dieudonne:
Go to Google and look up Magnetic Levitation. Find the pictures in How Things Work or similar sites.
Freddie
 
can an asterisk (eight lines to this asterisk) configuration of rectangular electromagnets (each magnet about 2.5"x1") generate enough attraction to pull an Earth magnet from one leg of the asterisk to the adjacent one? we are trying to make a slow moving magnetic drive system using electromagnets and Earth magnets. our evenutal hope is for our object on a bearing in the center of the asterisk to be able to turn and hold above each stick/leg of the asterisk as the magnets are energized and de-energized.
 
I'm having trouble picturing that one. Any chance of a picture?
 
  • #10
Here is what I would do , start with a circular tube of plastic .
put a cylindrical Neo magnet inside the tube.
wind a bunch of coils around the tube , the more the better , as you energize each coil in sequence , the magnet will jump forward .
use another Neo magnet inside a train car on a track above the coils , the magnet inside the tube should pull the car along the track.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K