Misner-Thorne-Wheeler, p.92, Box 4.1, typo?


by gheremond
Tags: misnerthornewheeler, typo
gheremond
gheremond is offline
#1
Oct26-09, 11:53 AM
P: 6
In Misner-Thorne-Wheeler Gravitation, Chapter 4, Page 92, Box 4.1, at section 4, there is a formula for the contraction of a p-form and a p-vector. Now, it states that the contraction of a p-form basis with a p-vector basis gives the antisymmetrizer symbol, [tex]\left\langle {\omega ^{i_1 } \wedge \ldots \wedge \omega ^{i_p } ,e_{j_1 } \wedge \ldots \wedge e_{j_p } } \right\rangle = \delta ^{i_1 \ldots i_p } _{j_1 \ldots j_p } [/tex] and there is a reference to exercises 3.13 and 4.12. I tried this part many many times and I always find the result to be p! times the antisymmetrizer. I also compared it for the case p=2 using the definition of the symbol from exercise 3.13, still the same result, I get an overall 2. Can anybody please explain what am I doing wrong here?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Cougars' diverse diet helped them survive the Pleistocene mass extinction
Cyber risks can cause disruption on scale of 2008 crisis, study says
Mantis shrimp stronger than airplanes
javierR
javierR is offline
#2
Oct26-09, 05:00 PM
P: 136
No typo. The symbol [tex]\delta^{ij}_{kl}\equiv \delta^{[i}_{k}\delta^{j]}_{l}\equiv \frac{1}{2!}\left(\delta^{i}_{k}\delta^{j}_{l}-\delta^{j}_{k}\delta^{i}_{l}\right)[/tex] (which generalizes to n indices with a 1/n! factor), and basis 1-forms act on basis vectors as [tex]\omega^{i}(e_{j})=\delta^{i}_{j}[/tex].
gheremond
gheremond is offline
#3
Oct26-09, 05:24 PM
P: 6
Thanks for the reply. However, if you look on page 88, you will see that the definition for [tex] \delta ^{\alpha \beta } _{\mu \nu } = \delta ^\alpha _\mu \delta ^\beta _\nu - \delta ^\alpha _\nu \delta ^\beta _\mu [/tex] according to MTW does not carry the 1/2! factor that you mention. Furthermore, if you expand the wedge products into tensor products within the contraction symbol, you get [tex]\left\langle {\omega ^\alpha \wedge \omega ^\beta ,e_\mu \wedge e_\nu } \right\rangle = \left\langle {\omega ^\alpha \otimes \omega ^\beta - \omega ^\beta \otimes \omega ^\alpha ,e_\mu \otimes e_\nu - e_\nu \otimes e_\mu } \right\rangle[/tex]

[tex] = \left\langle {\omega ^\alpha \otimes \omega ^\beta ,e_\mu \otimes e_\nu } \right\rangle - \left\langle {\omega ^\alpha \otimes \omega ^\beta ,e_\nu \otimes e_\mu } \right\rangle - \left\langle {\omega ^\beta \otimes \omega ^\alpha ,e_\mu \otimes e_\nu } \right\rangle + \left\langle {\omega ^\beta \otimes \omega ^\alpha ,e_\nu \otimes e_\mu } \right\rangle [/tex]

[tex] = \delta ^\alpha _\mu \delta ^\beta _\nu - \delta ^\alpha _\nu \delta ^\beta _\mu - \delta ^\beta _\mu \delta ^\alpha _\nu + \delta ^\beta _\nu \delta ^\alpha _\mu = 2\left( {\delta ^\alpha _\mu \delta ^\beta _\nu - \delta ^\alpha _\nu \delta ^\beta _\mu } \right) = 2 \delta ^{\alpha \beta } _{\mu \nu } [/tex]

again, using all the conventions of the book up to this point.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
help finding Kip Thorne web course Astrophysics 3
About the so-call "two errors (mistakes)" in Misner-Thorne-Wheeler Special & General Relativity 1
Gravitation - Thorne, Misner, Wheeler Science & Math Textbook Listings 6
Ex 2.1 in Misner Gravitaition Advanced Physics Homework 7
Weinberg vs. Misner, Thorne and Wheeler General Physics 5