image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Physics > Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics


Reply

image antibonding MO do they exist in reality? Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Nov8-09, 09:33 AM                  #1
sudar_dhoni

sudar_dhoni is Offline:
Posts: 48
antibonding MO do they exist in reality?

do antibonding molecular orbital exist in reality or
is it an empty space in which an electron can move about freely and not involving itself in bonding.
if they exist then how can the 2 atomic orbitals interfere both constructively as well as destructively simultaineously to give both Bonding as well as AntiBonding orbitals?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov8-09, 04:53 PM                  #2
wsttiger

wsttiger is Offline:
Posts: 10
Re: antibonding MO do they exist in reality?

Within the single-particle approximation, the antibonding orbital is an excited state of the molecule. Furthermore, in the ground state this orbital should be empty.

I'm not sure what you're asking in the second question. When you bring multiple atoms together, the Hamiltonian changes and thus the eigenstates of the Hamiltonian change. One way of describing the new eigenstates is to write them as linear combinations of the atomic orbitals. Basically, you're just using the atomic orbitals as a basis to construct the molecular orbitals (or eigenstates) of the new Hamiltonian.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov8-09, 05:24 PM                  #3
blkqi

blkqi is Offline:
Posts: 24
Re: antibonding MO do they exist in reality?

The plus OR minus represents two different possibilities. Bonding and anti-bonding do not occur in the same orbital. Electrons generally take the lower energy orbital, that is the bonding orbital. Antibonding occurs when two orbitals come together out of phase.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov9-09, 12:30 AM       Last edited by alxm; Nov9-09 at 12:35 AM..            #4
alxm

alxm is Offline:
Posts: 699
Re: antibonding MO do they exist in reality?

Originally Posted by sudar_dhoni View Post
do antibonding molecular orbital exist in reality or
is it an empty space in which an electron can move about freely and not involving itself in bonding.
Antibonding orbitals certainly exist. Orbitals are your solutions to the molecular schrödinger equation. Not all of these solutions correspond to 'bonding' patters, i.e. attraction between nuclei. The ones which are anti-bonding are generally the ones which have a node-plane (plane where the wave-function is zero, i.e. a change of sign) between the nuclei. More generally, such wavefunctions tend to be termed ungerade (German for 'odd'), whereas the 'bonding' orbitals are gerade ('even').

(The fact that they have a node is a clue to why they're usually higher in energy as well)

if they exist then how can the 2 atomic orbitals interfere both constructively as well as destructively simultaineously to give both Bonding as well as AntiBonding orbitals?
Ah! Now you get to the actual MO theory, which is to basically form the MO's by combining atomic orbitals. This is actually just an approximation, but it does qualitatively describe which MOs you end up with.

Anyway, the basic rationale for this is simple superposition. If A and B are your wave functions for individual atoms, then A + B is the wavefunction for the two of them together. (This is true if the electrons of the two atoms don't interact. Since they do interact, this becomes an approximation) But: A - B is a solution as well. That's superposition.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: antibonding MO do they exist in reality?
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Boundary between deterministic reality and probabilistic reality Galteeth Quantum Physics 20 Oct22-09 04:54 PM
Antibonding question bhannubhakta Chemistry 1 Mar18-09 02:25 AM
Bonding-Antibonding Pair question. dionysian Chemistry 5 Apr1-07 10:35 AM
In terms of mathmatical logical philosophy does reality have to exist? Mohaamad Philosophy 11 May28-03 08:05 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image