image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

image Oh I need some help. Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Nov24-09, 02:31 PM                  #1
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Oh I need some help.

Hi guys

I'm new here and needed some help with an idea i have. I am trying to work out how much torque/power a single piston engine will have, after i have designed it. I know how much force there wil be on the piston (in lds) at all positions of the piston. I gather i need to work out the leverage on the crack.

Is there a web site i can read about how to work this out?

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 02:43 PM                  #2
xxChrisxx

xxChrisxx is Offline:
Posts: 874
Re: Oh I need some help.

Do you have the geometry and weights of the components?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 02:47 PM                  #3
berkeman

PF Mentor
 
berkeman's Avatar

berkeman is Offline:
Posts: 15,946
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by gareth01422 View Post
Hi guys

I'm new here and needed some help with an idea i have. I am trying to work out how much torque/power a single piston engine will have, after i have designed it. I know how much force there wil be on the piston (in lds) at all positions of the piston. I gather i need to work out the leverage on the crack.

Is there a web site i can read about how to work this out?

Gaz
Have you had basic trigonometry? What math classes have you had? What physics classes?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 02:54 PM                  #4
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by berkeman View Post
Have you had basic trigonometry? What math classes have you had? What physics classes?
I am studying with the open university at the moment only just touching on physics at the minute (studying a book called Energy and light). So i have basic maths skills but learning all the time.

Also I have a modle drawn up in CAD (solidworks).

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 03:12 PM                  #5
xxChrisxx

xxChrisxx is Offline:
Posts: 874
Re: Oh I need some help.

Good good, well you can use the following method.

You need to plot the gas pressure force vs crank angle. Then to find the inertia force of the piston going up and down, and plot that vs crank angle.

You can combine these two fo find the force acting down the cylinder axis. The graph should look like this:


You acn then use this figure to work out the torque, at the crankshaft using the folling equation.


From that you get a graph of torque vs crank angle. Fin the average torque and work out power from that.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 03:17 PM                  #6
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by xxChrisxx View Post
Good good, well you can use the following method.

You need to plot the gas pressure force vs crank angle. Then to find the inertia force of the piston going up and down, and plot that vs crank angle.

You can combine these two fo find the force acting down the cylinder axis. The graph should look like this:


You acn then use this figure to work out the torque, at the crankshaft using the folling equation.




From that you get a graph of torque vs crank angle. Fin the average torque and work out power from that.
This is great stuff.

I can easily find out what presure is on the piston as it pushes down, on the up stroke it will be inertia from the fly wheel. Do I find out the presures for every 5 degrees or do i go for 10 degrees?

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 03:21 PM                  #7
xxChrisxx

xxChrisxx is Offline:
Posts: 874
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by gareth01422 View Post
This is great stuff.

I can easily find out what presure is on the piston as it pushes down, on the up stroke it will be inertia from the fly wheel. Do I find out the presures for every 5 degrees or do i go for 10 degrees?

Gaz
Thats a judgement call, as with any other numerical simulation, the smaller the timestep the more accurate but time consuming it is.

Only you can judge the level of accuracy required. Tbh I can't remember what I used, but just that I got to within 5% accuracy. I didnt have a plot of gas pressure force I had to construct one and had to estimate pumping losses.

Note that at high engine speeds, the torque graph looks very funny, this is becuase inertia forces dominate and the gas pressure makes no difference. The average torque should always be the same though, if the gas pressures are constant (they arent in realisty, but i made that assumption)
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 03:23 PM                  #8
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by xxChrisxx View Post
Thats a judgement call, as with any other numerical simulation, the smaller the timestep the more accurate but time consuming it is.

Only you can judge the level of accuracy required. Tbh I can't remember what I used, but just that I got to within 5% accuracy. I didnt have a plot of gas pressure force I had to construct one and had to estimate pumping losses.

Note that at high engine speeds, the torque graph looks very funny, this is becuase inertia forces dominate and the gas pressure makes no difference. The average torque should always be the same though.
Chris

Thanks for the help, I may call back and need more guidance if thats ok. I will put my pressures into a excel spreadsheet like yours to start of with, This will take me a while.

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 03:35 PM                  #9
xxChrisxx

xxChrisxx is Offline:
Posts: 874
Re: Oh I need some help.

No problem bud.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 04:02 PM                  #10
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by xxChrisxx View Post
No problem bud.
Hi chris

So Ive got pressures for every 10 degrees from TDC (top dead centre). apart from the up stroke,

How do i calculate the inertia of the fly wheel as that is what it will need to push the piston back up. Also will i need to include this in the pressures for the down stroke?

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 05:18 PM                  #11
xxChrisxx

xxChrisxx is Offline:
Posts: 874
Re: Oh I need some help.

You dont need to know the flywheel inertia.

You can work this out directly from the mathematical equation determining the acceleration of the piston.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 05:19 PM                  #12
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by xxChrisxx View Post
You dont need to know the flywheel inertia.

You can work this out directly from the mathematical equation determining the acceleration of the piston.
Ok so where do i go from here?

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 05:25 PM                  #13
xxChrisxx

xxChrisxx is Offline:
Posts: 874
Re: Oh I need some help.

It's time to dig out the maths books, and do some horrid derivation i'm afraid.

Or if you dont need to show derication, google piston acceleration. It'll give an equation in terms of crank angle and engine speed.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 05:30 PM                  #14
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Chris

Once again, thanks for the help.

Ive found this website, Is this what i should be reading through and applying to my piston engine?

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 07:12 PM                  #15
berkeman

PF Mentor
 
berkeman's Avatar

berkeman is Offline:
Posts: 15,946
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by gareth01422 View Post
Chris

Once again, thanks for the help.

Ive found this website, Is this what i should be reading through and applying to my piston engine?

Gaz
You found what website?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov25-09, 05:06 AM                  #16
gareth01422

gareth01422 is Offline:
Posts: 25
Re: Oh I need some help.

Originally Posted by berkeman View Post
You found what website?
Sorry I forgot to add the link.

http://www.marinediesels.info/2_stro...movement_2.htm

Gaz
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image