Super nerd poll: Kirk or Picard?

Galteeth

For the ladies or gay dudes, who is hotter (character, not the actor) and why?


Could be a fun topic.



Note: Mods, if the post is too nerdy/silly feel free to delete, i won't be offended.

Math Is Hard

My vote goes to Kirk in this contest.

(But actually Mr. Chekov was my first Star Trek crush.)

Sorry!

oh boy kirk by far.

Greg Bernhardt

kirk, but i'd rather picard as my dad

Evo

Picard.

Sorry!

Reason being for kirk?: He just 'does it for me' haha -no homo (can I say that?)

mcknia07

Kirk is way cuter! Picard, well.... he's just too old for my taste.

TheStatutoryApe

Oops... I voted before I realized what exactly the poll is. Its one of those geek knee jerk answers: Kirk or Picard, Star Wars or Star Trek, Marvel or DC....

I would still consider Picard an attractive man though. He has certainly aged better than Kirk in my opinion.

Moonbear

Definitely Kirk! Younger and cuter. Picard is more the grandfatherly type.

TheStatutoryApe

That doesn't seem very fair. How about we compare them at the same approximate ages. Stewart is nine years younger. So The Search for Spock[1984] vs Generations[1994]?


Sorry I couldn't find a pic from that movie without Kirk in it too. One may want to note that Kirk had supposedly taken to wearing toupees and girdles by the point the first picture was taken.

Or we could go the other direction.


I could not find what year that pic of Stewart was taken. Shatner was about 35 when Star Trek started.

Evo

Comparing Picard with old Kirk, Picard is the hands down winner.

Lisa!

Am I missing something here?


"For the ladies or gay dudes, who is hotter (character, not the actor) and why?"






Oh and as for the question of the OP:Kirk!

Sorry!

Evo

I already posted the votes for the people that voted before my post #5 when I added the poll. If you didn't realize this and voted again, please let me know.

turbo

I have no preference, but I can tell you that my sisters watched Star Trek for Kirk. Just like Gunsmoke, but set in space with a randier "sheriff".

They watched cowboy shows for the leading males, too. Sugarfoot, Rawhide, Bonanza...

Evo

I watched Star Trek for Spock.

Astronuc

Me too Spock was my favorite character, and it was my nickname in elementary school and junior high.

I like the early Kirk and Picard.