Why are insects attracted to feces?


by wasteofo2
Tags: attracted, feces, insects
wasteofo2
wasteofo2 is offline
#1
Aug9-04, 10:10 AM
wasteofo2's Avatar
P: 1,522
I'm sure everyone's seen some dog crap lying on the street and a bunch of flies swarming around it, why does this happen? Are they after some left-over organic materials in the feces, or do they have any use for the inorganic waste products in their metabolism?
Phys.Org News Partner Biology news on Phys.org
Declining catch rates in Caribbean green turtle fishery may be result of overfishing
Chimpanzees prefer firm, stable beds
For cells, internal stress leads to unique shapes
marcus
marcus is online now
#2
Aug9-04, 10:30 AM
Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
marcus's Avatar
P: 22,796
Quote Quote by wasteofo2
I'm sure everyone's seen some dog crap lying on the street and a bunch of flies swarming around it, why does this happen? Are they after some left-over organic materials in the feces, or do they have any use for the inorganic waste products in their metabolism?
what a disgusting topic to raise
however one can ask: what is doo-doo made of?
I would guess that it contains the bodies of bacteria that flourish in
the mammalian gut, and lots of organic fiber----cellulose

some expert will no doubt descend, flapping his or her bat-like wings, and tell us what poop is really made of

but let us suppose that I am right
think about this: cellulose (which we cannot digest because we do not produce the enzyme cellulase to break it down into sugar) is a polymerized sugar. Therefore indigestible fiber is good food for any small beastie that can make the right enzyme.

the Fabled Amerinds who once roamed the Great Plains used to build their campfires of Buffalo dung---which shows that, far from being inorganic, faeces are a rich source of calories---they burn when dry.

Therefore, from a fly-maggot's point of view----hatched in the dung where his mother thoughtfully laid her eggs----it is a wholesome provender
iansmith
iansmith is offline
#3
Aug9-04, 11:05 AM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
iansmith's Avatar
P: 1,430
Flies are attracted to warm moist place to lay eggs such as feces. Feces are also rich in decaying matter and the larvae will feed on the decaying matter. The bacteria in the feces are doing all the job.

wasteofo2
wasteofo2 is offline
#4
Aug9-04, 11:37 AM
wasteofo2's Avatar
P: 1,522

Why are insects attracted to feces?


Quote Quote by marcus
what a disgusting topic to raise
however one can ask: what is doo-doo made of?
I would guess that it contains the bodies of bacteria that flourish in
the mammalian gut, and lots of organic fiber----cellulose

some expert will no doubt descend, flapping his or her bat-like wings, and tell us what poop is really made of

but let us suppose that I am right
think about this: cellulose (which we cannot digest because we do not produce the enzyme cellulase to break it down into sugar) is a polymerized sugar. Therefore indigestible fiber is good food for any small beastie that can make the right enzyme.

the Fabled Amerinds who once roamed the Great Plains used to build their campfires of Buffalo dung---which shows that, far from being inorganic, faeces are a rich source of calories---they burn when dry.

Therefore, from a fly-maggot's point of view----hatched in the dung where his mother thoughtfully laid her eggs----it is a wholesome provender
If flys loved cellulose, it would seem they'd all eat grass...

Just because something burns, doesn't mean it's organic, or else methane would be considered organic, right?
selfAdjoint
selfAdjoint is offline
#5
Aug9-04, 03:48 PM
Emeritus
PF Gold
P: 8,147
Quote Quote by wasteofo2
If flys loved cellulose, it would seem they'd all eat grass...

Just because something burns, doesn't mean it's organic, or else methane would be considered organic, right?
What we mammals egest is too low in free energy for us to exploit for order building anymore, but not zero in free energy. Specialized creatures, both insects and bacteria, can extract some of the remaining free energy from our poop to generate their own order building operations.
marcus
marcus is online now
#6
Aug9-04, 04:10 PM
Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
marcus's Avatar
P: 22,796
Quote Quote by wasteofo2
If flys loved cellulose, it would seem they'd all eat grass...

Just because something burns, doesn't mean it's organic, or else methane would be considered organic, right?
methane is classified as an organic chemical

My CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics has two sets of data on compounds, organic and inorganic, and methane is in the organic list.

carbon compounds often are treated as organic and methane is CH4

I wonder if fly larvae can actually feed on the bacteria that are thriving on the egested waste----yoghurt is made of the bodies of bacteria IIRC---perhaps the fly larvae think they are amidst a sort of yoghurt
iansmith
iansmith is offline
#7
Aug9-04, 04:24 PM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
iansmith's Avatar
P: 1,430
Quote Quote by marcus
I wonder if fly larvae can actually feed on the bacteria that are thriving on the egested waste----yoghurt is made of the bodies of bacteria IIRC---perhaps the fly larvae think they are amidst a sort of yoghurt
Fly larvae probably feed on bacteria but I think is more acidental than anything else. On a side note, when you eat yoghurt there is 10^9 bacteria per gram.
marcus
marcus is online now
#8
Aug9-04, 05:47 PM
Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
marcus's Avatar
P: 22,796
Quote Quote by iansmith
On a side note, when you eat yoghurt there is 10^9 bacteria per gram.
you say but I say Yum Yum for yoghurt!

I would rather eat a trillion bacteria than one kilo of cow
Janitor
Janitor is offline
#9
Aug9-04, 07:24 PM
Sci Advisor
P: 1,190
Theoretically there was a leash law in the neighborhood where I grew up. Despite said law, one undeniable hazard of playing front-yard tackle football (in addition to a knee injury that still can cause me problems to this day) was that a puff of white smoke would sometimes spray from underneath a tackled player. Somebody made the claim that it was white due to a dominant presence of the element phosphorus, but I never knew how valid this claim was.
wasteofo2
wasteofo2 is offline
#10
Aug9-04, 09:10 PM
wasteofo2's Avatar
P: 1,522
Quote Quote by marcus
methane is classified as an organic chemical

My CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics has two sets of data on compounds, organic and inorganic, and methane is in the organic list.

carbon compounds often are treated as organic and methane is CH4

I wonder if fly larvae can actually feed on the bacteria that are thriving on the egested waste----yoghurt is made of the bodies of bacteria IIRC---perhaps the fly larvae think they are amidst a sort of yoghurt
Alright, well bad example. But you get my point right, not everything that burns must be a hydrocarbon.
marcus
marcus is online now
#11
Aug9-04, 09:59 PM
Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
marcus's Avatar
P: 22,796
Quote Quote by wasteofo2
Alright, well bad example. But you get my point right, not everything that burns must be a hydrocarbon.
Of course I get your point! I am not correcting you I am talking with you.

wood is an organic chemical----not a hydrocarbon but mostly cellulose which is a carbohydate not too different from sugar

on the other hand pure hydrogen gas is not classified as organic (it has no carbon in it)

neither does sodium metal and magnesium powder

hydrogen and sodium and magnesium burn but they are not organic


however most fuels are classified by chemists as organic

to a chemist an organic chemical does not have to be one produced by a living organism..some meteorites contain organic compounds which were just in the organic crude the solar system condensed from---not made by life.

professionals are endlessly inventive about screwing up language
just some thoughts


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Why would dust be attracted to a CD wiped with a dry cloth? General Physics 2
KE of electron being attracted by 2 protons Introductory Physics Homework 4
'There is no law against using feces as a flag stand' General Discussion 8
can photons be attracted to one another? Quantum Physics 20