
#1
Feb1411, 03:39 AM

P: 33

Hi
As two stars orbit their mutual center of mass in elliptical orbits, why are their eccentricity the same? And why is it the same as the one of reduced mass around center of mass? Thanks 



#2
Feb1411, 02:13 PM

P: 514

Their positions are weighted mirror images of each other:
x1 =  m2/(m1+m2) * x12 x2 = m1/(m1+m2) * x12 where x12 = x2  x1 and their center of mass is fixed: m1*x1 + m2*x2 = 0 Let's now consider mutual interactions: m1*d^{2}(x1)/dt^{2} =  f m2*d^{2}(x2)/dt^{2} = + f The forces are reversed in sign from Newton's Third Law, with the consequence that d^{2}(m1*x1+m2*x2)/dt^{2} = 0 Plug the formulas for x1 and x2 into these equations of motion, and one gets m_{reduced}*d^{2}(x12)/dt^{2} = + f where m_{reduced} = m1*m2/(m1+m2) Alternatively, d^{2}(x1)/dt^{2} = (1/m1)*f d^{2}(x2)/dt^{2} = (1/m2)*f with d^{2}(x12)/dt^{2} = (1/m1 + 1/m2)*f 



#3
Feb1411, 03:09 PM

P: 33

thank you very much!




#4
Feb2611, 06:13 AM

P: 2

the eccentricity of binary stars' orbits
So, why are the eccentricities the same?




#5
Feb2611, 10:06 AM

P: 33

As I understood, the distance of M1 to CM, x1, is linearly proportional to the distance of M2 to CM, and also it is proportional to the distance between these two, x12.
Since x1 is an ellipse with eccentricity e1, its eccentricity remains constant, but its semimajor gets multiplied, when it is multiplied by a constant number. So we have a bigger/smaller ellipse with the same eccentricity. 



#6
Feb2611, 11:16 AM

P: 2

Ok, I couldn't figure it out. Thanks a lot!




#7
Mar911, 08:01 AM

P: 1

I am wondering how the eccentricity of a circumbinary (binary star system) planet is defined? To my knowledge Kepler elements, including e, are noninertial elements. So, how is the planets eccentricity measured?




#8
Mar1111, 01:10 PM

P: 6

Well, the planet's orbit will have to be stable enough to be an ellipse, which assumes it's quite far away from the apoapsis distance of the stars (AFAIRemember >12*a).
Anyway, a circumbinary orbit should have it's Kepler elements defined w.r.t the binary system's barycenter. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Binary Stars  Cosmology  0  
how is the eccentricity of planetary orbits related to the direction and movement of  General Astronomy  0  
Binary Stars  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
binary stars  Introductory Physics Homework  7  
Question on binary stars & binary stars  Introductory Physics Homework  1 