# In General Relativity, what would happen to the Earth the Sun disappeared?

Tags: disappeared, earth, happen, relativity
 P: 83 I'm not sure if this is in the right forum. If the Sun disappeared, would the Earth's velocity change? Since the space-time fabric would 'spring' back into it's normal position, the effect of gravity on the Earth would dissipate? Thus, resulting in the Earth being thrown out of it's orbit?
PF Gold
P: 5,448
 Quote by MegaDeth I'm not sure if this is in the right forum. If the Sun disappeared, would the Earth's velocity change? Since the space-time fabric would 'spring' back into it's normal position, the effect of gravity on the Earth would dissipate? Thus, resulting in the Earth being thrown out of it's orbit?
What orbit? If the sun disappeared, then 8 minutes later the earth would HAVE no orbit because it would have nothing to orbit AROUND. It would just keep going in whatever direction it was headed in 8 minutes after the sun disappeared.
P: 83
 Quote by phinds What orbit? If the sun disappeared, then 8 minutes later the earth would HAVE no orbit because it would have nothing to orbit AROUND. It would just keep going in whatever direction it was headed in 8 minutes after the sun disappeared.
Yes, I know that, but what I'm asking is, would it's velocity change since there's no gravity acting upon it from the Sun which has disappeared?

Emeritus
PF Gold
P: 5,415

## In General Relativity, what would happen to the Earth the Sun disappeared?

You're going to end up in a logically self-contradictory position if you try to answer this question within GR. GR has local conservation of mass-energy, and therefore it doesn't allow the sun to disappear. GR becomes logically inconsistent if you assume violation of conservation of mass-energy.

If the sun was suddenly ripped out of the solar system and taken far away, GR says that the disturbance in the gravitational field would travel at c, so the earth would continue in its original orbit for another 8 minutes.
P: 83
 Quote by bcrowell You're going to end up in a logically self-contradictory position if you try to answer this question within GR. GR has local conservation of mass-energy, and therefore it doesn't allow the sun to disappear. GR becomes logically inconsistent if you assume violation of conservation of mass-energy. If the sun was suddenly ripped out of the solar system and taken far away, GR says that the disturbance in the gravitational field would travel at c, so the earth would continue in its original orbit for another 8 minutes.
Thanks, that has helped me a lot. By gravitational field, I assume you're referring to the curvature of space-time?
Emeritus
PF Gold
P: 5,415
 Quote by MegaDeth Thanks, that has helped me a lot. By gravitational field, I assume you're referring to the curvature of space-time?
Right.

 Related Discussions Astrophysics 12 General Physics 75 Classical Physics 4 Advanced Physics Homework 0 General Physics 0