New Reply

Where am I going wrong? Thermo derivation..

 
Share Thread
Oct13-11, 08:36 AM   #1
 

Where am I going wrong? Thermo derivation..


Derive the fundamental equations of thermodynamics for an open system containing a onecomponent fluid in terms of the intensive internal energy U = U/N, the intensive Helmholtz free energy A, the intensive Gibbs free energy G, and the intensive enthalpy H. For each of the equations write the one associated Maxwell relation. Hint: The starting point should be
U = −pV + TS + μ. U = (U/N) etc..

Right, so I can do it in therms of U, however I'm stuck on A and some others.. my working below:

For A:

A=-ST - pV + μ

dA = d(A/N) = (1/N)dA + Ad(1/N)

= (1/N)(-SdT - pdV + μdN) + d(1/N)(-ST - pV + μ)

Recognising that: dV(underlined) = NdV + NVd(1/N) .. I'm guessing I need to eliminate dV? I'm not sure why though... :S

dA = (1/N)[-SdT - p(NdV + nVd(1/N)) + μdN] + [-STd(1/N) - pVd(1/N) + μd(1/N)]

= -SdT - pdV + (μ/N)dN + μd(1/N) - STd(1/N)

I can't get the last 3 terms in bold to disappear.. help! Anyone know what I'm doing wrong?

Its meant to go down to dA = -SdT - pdV


Many thanks
PhysOrg.com engineering news on PhysOrg.com

>> Mathematical algorithms cut train delays
>> Researchers design software to detect changes in colour vision
>> Trend study identifies potential for humans and technology to interact in a manufacturing environment
Oct13-11, 10:08 PM   #2
 
Recognitions:
Gold Membership Gold Member
Homework Helper Homework Help
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Your definition of A is off: A=U-TS.
New Reply

Tags
derivation, engineering, helmholtz, thermodynamics

Similar discussions for: Where am I going wrong? Thermo derivation..
Thread Forum Replies
Help with a thermo derivation? Classical Physics 1
[Thermo] Derivation of compressibility factor vs reduced pressure Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 2
Thermo Derivation Classical Physics 3
1D Thermo problem, something is wrong... Introductory Physics Homework 1
A wrong derivation of E=MC^2 General Physics 0