Register to reply 
A force acts on a particle based on position, determine work. Sign question. 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb1912, 10:30 PM

P: 5

I have a question about this problem in relation to the way the solution manual handles it.
1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data A force F_{x} acts on a particle of mass 1.5kg. The force is related to the position x of the particle by the formula F_{x} = Cx^{3}, where C = .50. IF x is in maters and F_{x} is in newtons. (a) What are the SI units of C? (b) Find the work done by this force as the particle moves from x = 3.0m to x = 1.5 m. (c) At x = 3.0m the force points in the opposite direction of the particles velocity (speed is 12m/s) What is its speed at x = 1.5m? Ignore (a) 2. Relevant equations [itex]W = \int F_{x} dx[/itex] [itex] W = \frac{1}{2}{mv}^{2}_{f}  \frac{1}{2}{mv}^{2}_{i}[/itex] F_{x} = Cx^{3} 3. The attempt at a solution Okay, when I solved the problem I used the first equation which gave me 9.5 Joules. [itex]W = {\int}^{1.5m}_{3.0m} .5x^{3} dx = 9.5 Joules[/itex] However, when I referenced the solution manual, they placed a negative sign in front of F_{x} in the equation because the force is "in the opposite direction of the displacement." [itex]W = {\int}^{1.5m}_{3.0m} .5x^{3} dx = 9.5 Joules[/itex] This made no sense to me because the velocity of the particle is, from what I can tell, equal to 12m/s because the force function is always positive. So, it only makes sense to me that the force should be slowing the particle down since the particle is moving in the opposite direction of the force. Consequently, because of the sign conversion, this throws off the answer to c as well because when I calculated the velocity with the negative work the velocity came out to 11.46m/s however, because the manual claims the work was positive, their result was 13m/s. Derived Equation: [itex]\sqrt{\frac{2W+m{v}^{2}_{i}}{m}} = v_f[/itex] I can not make sense of why the solution manual flipped the sign of the force function. 


#2
Feb1912, 10:40 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 11,869

The solution manual is wrong. You're right.
What the solution manual is trying to explain is that the force ##\vec{F}## and the displacement ##d\vec{x}## point in the opposite direction, so $$dW=\vec{F}\cdot d\vec{x} = \vec{F}d\vec{x}\cos 180^\circ = \vec{F}d\vec{x}$$What the person who wrote the solution missed was the fact that ##d\vec{x} = dx## because the lower limit of the integral is greater than the upper limit, so the work is given by $$W = \int \vec{F}d\vec{x} = +\int_{3.0\text{ m}}^{1.5\text{ m}} Cx^3\,dx$$ as you had. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Force acts on a particle  Introductory Physics Homework  2  
Determine work done by force F  Introductory Physics Homework  2  
How to determine a particle's position given the velocitytime graph and unknowns?  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
How to determine Force from hor. position vector?  Advanced Physics Homework  1  
Position vector of a moving particle (calc based intro)  Introductory Physics Homework  4 