Incest. Does it really produce retards?

  • Thread starter Thread starter pikapika!
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the genetic implications of incest, particularly focusing on the potential for genetic disorders and traits that may arise from inbreeding. Participants explore various aspects of genetic weaknesses, recessive traits, and the societal perceptions of related terms.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that incest reinforces genetic weaknesses, citing examples such as color blindness and physical deformities observed in historical figures like Egyptian pharaohs.
  • Others argue that incest increases the likelihood of rare recessive traits manifesting, using the example of lab retrievers to illustrate how pure breeding can lead to genetic disorders.
  • A participant with color blindness defends the condition, highlighting potential advantages and questioning the notion of it being a weakness.
  • Inbreeding depression is mentioned as a concept where inbreeding can lead to decreased overall fitness of traits.
  • There is a discussion about the nature of mutations, with a participant recalling that most mutations may be recessive, seeking clarification on this point.
  • Several posts address the use of the term "retard," with participants discussing its derogatory implications and the importance of using more accurate and respectful language when referring to individuals with cognitive disabilities.
  • One participant emphasizes the misleading nature of the term "colorblind," suggesting that it oversimplifies the experience of those with color vision deficiencies.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

The discussion contains multiple competing views on the implications of incest and genetic disorders, with no consensus reached on the definitions or appropriateness of certain terms used in the context of cognitive disabilities.

Contextual Notes

Participants express varying definitions and perceptions of genetic conditions and disabilities, indicating a lack of clarity and agreement on terminology and its implications.

pikapika!
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
I can't remember what i was told but in science class the teacher just said that incest just enforced the weaknesses in your genes such as color blindness.

Also, I was watching this documentry once of how egyptian phaoros often had children from incest and as a resultant they had deformations like abnormally large hips and as a result of there deformations didnt live as long.
 
Biology news on Phys.org
pikapika! said:
I can't remember what i was told but in science class the teacher just said that incest just enforced the weaknesses in your genes such as color blindness.

Also, I was watching this documentry once of how egyptian phaoros often had children from incest and as a resultant they had deformations like abnormally large hips and as a result of there deformations didnt live as long.

"retards"? Let me guess you were going for the politically correct look.

Incest increases the chance of rare recessive traits showing up. For example, if a man has an allele of a rare genetic disorder, which is a recessive than it is very unlikely for that person to mate with a another person who also has the recessive allele. So most likely the trait will never show up. But, if the same man mates with his sister, there is a very good likelyhood that she too will have the recessive allele - so most likely their offspring will inherit the 2 recessive alleles, which will cause the trait to be manefested.

An example of this is lab retrievers. They are breed very pure, but b/c of this the is a rare hip disorder that is displayed in an unusually large number of dogs.

Nautica
 
pikapika! said:
the weaknesses in your genes such as color blindness.
Since I am a person who has been genetically diagnosed as colorblind (I do not have the gene for green cones, therefore I am a deuteromorph, the most common type) I guess it falls upon me top defend our so-called "weakness".

Despite my inability to sometimes correctly match certain items of clothing (my wife is very handy for this), I hardly find this a detriment to my life and I would also point out some of the known advantages of colorblindness. Our ability to ignore certain shades allows us to better define edge/outline characteristics and makes us less likely to be fooled by camouflage. This attribute was and probably still is utilized by military forces who prize the colorblind sniper. Also our night vision is typically better than the average person, I believe due to the shift in rod/cone numbers. Thus these advantages probably dictate the prevalence of colorblindness in our society (~8-10% of males) as it carried a fitness advantage to our hunter-gatherer ancestors.
 
We also call this inbreeding depression, where inbreeding causes the decrease in overall fitness of a trait.
 
I seem to recall reading somewhere that most mutations were recessive in nature. Is that true? And if so, why?
 
thanks for your info on color blindness. but id still rather see a rainbow with all its colors.
 
pikapika! said:
thanks for your info on color blindness. but id still rather see a rainbow with all its colors.

well, if you were raised as not seeing any different, it might not make any difference. the term color blind is such a limited term. there are many "colors" we cannot detect, so by your definition, you are colorblind, unless you can see ultraviolet light. :rolleyes:

and i suggest you do a little more research on what a retard is, as the context of how you used it in this topic is quite degrading to a group of people who enhance lives in ways you might not expect.
 
What is the politically correct term? metally challenged. I thought that was scientific term.
 
While it is true that terms like cretin, idiot, moron and mentally retarded originate from medical and judiciary circles, such labels are rarely used today, even in science, and are typically associated with offensive and/or derogatory statements. Generally when referring to individuals who live with such conditions the exact syndrome, disease, etc is used, i.e., Down's syndrome, Asperger's..., rather than lumping vastly differing levels of functioning, even within a single disease-type, into some convenient class.

Definition's for mentally retarded status are easily found on the web or one can check the latest Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) at most libraries. You will probably find that most of the definitions are associated with law and judiciary procedures. These remain because changing laws that are on the books is a particularly complicated task.

pikapika! said:
thanks for your info on color blindness. but id still rather see a rainbow with all its colors.
The term "colorblind" is rather misleading as Kerrie states. I can see all primary colors and enjoy a rainbow as much as the next person. Where it comes into play is in shading between colors. Thus on a graded color scale between green and brown, what you might call brown, I see as green, but at either end I can see the parent colors. True colorblindness, or monochromacy, results in seeing only black, white and shades of gray and is extremely rare. Check out this website for an excellent review of colorblindness and a chance to see how I experience things. http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/java/humanvision/colorblindness/
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
4K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
5K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K
Replies
27
Views
7K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 67 ·
3
Replies
67
Views
17K
Replies
26
Views
9K