
#1
Jan1205, 01:55 AM

P: 2

I vaguely remember a physics teacher once telling me that it is impossible to suck water through a straw that is longer than 32 feet because the air preassure is not strong enough to push it that high when you create a vacuum in your mouth. I know the mechanics behind sucking water through a straw, so that kinda makes sense to me.
My question is, if it is true, would the straw have to be 32 feet high, or can it be on it's side across a table ( or something to that affect)? /edit for da_willem. my understanding of the mechanics was by no means worded correctly last time, please correct me if I am still wrong. 



#2
Jan1205, 02:27 AM

P: 603

Ofcourse it has to be 32 feet (actually 9,81m) high . Are you sure understand the mechanics behind sucking water through a straw?




#3
Jan1205, 02:28 AM

Mentor
P: 7,292

The straw will work as long as the difference in height between the 2 ends is less then 32ft. When you reduce the pressure above the water in the straw, atmospheric pressure will push the fluid up into the straw. But the atmosphere can only support a column of water 32ft high. So the atmosphere can only push the water up 32ft.




#4
Jan1205, 03:27 AM

P: 2

air pressure: water through a straw
thanks for the verification Integral. Now, I'm going to find 33 feet of straw, and a 33 foot balcony to prove this to my friends who refuse to believe me




#5
Jan1205, 06:27 AM

Math
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 38,886

In other words, if you were a "perfect sucker" (there's one born every minute!) you could produce a perfect vacuum above the water: there would be no air pressure above it so air pressure on the surface of the water would push it up the straw. It can do that until the weight of the water in the straw (downward) is equal to the force of air pressure (upward). Yes, the straw has to be vertical.




#6
Jan1205, 08:02 AM

Mentor
P: 22,001





#7
Jan1205, 08:19 AM

P: 15,325

Alas, your experiment is doomed. Even presuming you have olympiclevel suction ability, the straw will collapse. Any material that is not strong enough to hold a vacuum will collapse.




#8
Jan1205, 03:57 PM

P: 207

You can do this in water also. Get a pipe about 3 or 4 foot long and see how far you can go down under water and still breathe. You probabally wont make the 3 foot mark.




#9
Jan1305, 01:17 PM

P: 1

Clart pipe



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Water pressure  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
Fluid Mechanics  Highest Possible Water Can go in a Straw  Advanced Physics Homework  5  
Water depth pressure against air pressure  Classical Physics  1  
Water Pressure  Introductory Physics Homework  2  
why does the water shoot up out of the straw at the top  Introductory Physics Homework  19 