|Jul5-12, 04:04 PM||#1|
Why is the Universe electrically neutral?
That's a conundrum that I've seen posed -- certain people have claimed that it's very improbable.
But here is what I think is a plausible solution. If the Universe originated from a quantum fluctuation or something similar, it would have to have originated as a gauge singlet. Being a gauge singlet means having zero electric charge, thus implying that the Universe is electrically neutral.
|Jul6-12, 07:35 AM||#2|
Which changes to the question of why it has to be a gauge singlet of course. Discovery that the Universe is not electrically neutral would mean that the gauge-singlet idea of the creation of matter is wrong and we'd have to come up with something else. So - is this a strong argument?
"Certain people" would be the "Electric Universe" and "Plasma Cosmology" crowd?
Some discussions into why it is likely that the Universe is electrically neutral:
The question of how it came to be that the Universe is charge-neutral on the large scale is quite deep ... a simple look:
... gives some of the idea.
|Jul6-12, 11:24 AM||#3|
In post #39 that thread, xantox proposed that the Universe is electrically neutral (total charge = 0) because of gauge symmetry.
I think that that's another version of the gauge-singlet idea.
That's because one can always find a gauge-symmetry operator that can transform one member into another of an irreducible-representation gauge multiplet. Only for a singlet is there only one member to choose from.
|Similar Threads for: Why is the Universe electrically neutral?|
|Are electrically neutral particles invisible?||High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics||2|
|electrically neutral||Introductory Physics Homework||4|
|Proof That the Universe is Electrically Neutral||Cosmology||41|
|Evidence that the Universe is Electrically Neutral||Advanced Physics Homework||3|
|Are atoms electrically neutral?||General Physics||3|