
#1
Mar313, 07:51 AM

P: 1

I began applying first law of thermodynamics (delQ=dE+delW) to a freely falling body.
We see that for this case delQ=0, so dE=delW. As dE consists of both potential and kinetic energies we see that neglecting any viscous losses, dE=0. (At max. height, KE=0,PE=mgh and at bottom most point PE=0,KE=.5*m*v^2=mgh). This concludes that delW=0. But what happens to the work done by gravity? Is there any restriction placed on delW to be used in first law? If you say that work done by the gravity is compensated by change in potential energy, how to convey this using first law of thermodynamics? 



#2
Mar313, 08:01 AM

Mentor
P: 40,883

So choose one or the other, but not both. 



#3
Mar413, 12:32 AM

P: 35

It is an interesting question. It helps clarify many interesting aspects of thermodynamics.
First law of thermodynamics concerns with internal energy changes of the system as a result of interactions with the surroundings. In the question under consideration, the system (assuming it to be a rigid solid mass that suffers no change of shape as it falls) suffers no internal energy change. Consequently the algebraic sum of heat interaction and work interaction with the surroundings must be zero. Since heat interaction is zero work interaction is necessarily zero. Having said that, I may ask you to ponder over what your system is, what the surroundings is and how to account for work interaction between system and surroundings in any problem you tackle in thermodynamics. That helps, I hope, clarify the concepts in thermodynamics to a large extent. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Thermodynamics Zemansky Heat and Thermodynamics book question  Advanced Physics Homework  0  
Thermodynamics and Statistical Thermodynamics References  Science & Math Textbook Listings  9  
Physical Chemistry books (Thermodynamics/Statistical Thermodynamics/Kinetics/QM)  Science & Math Textbook Listings  1  
Thermodynamics: violation of 1st and/or 2nd law of thermodynamics in a heat engine  Introductory Physics Homework  7  
Prof teaches Statistical thermodynamics in a Classical Thermodynamics class  Academic Guidance  10 