Heat Transfer in Freezer: Solve the Problem with John

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a heat transfer problem involving a 200g water and an aluminum cup in a freezer, with subsequent heating to 96°C. The problem also explores a variation with an iron cup and ethyl alcohol, focusing on the heat required for temperature changes and phase transitions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss using the specific heat formula and the need to account for phase changes, such as melting ice. There are questions about whether to add heat calculations for the aluminum cup to the total heat required for the water.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, checking each other's calculations and assumptions. Some have pointed out the importance of considering latent heat and the implications of using different materials. There is no explicit consensus, but several productive lines of reasoning are being explored.

Contextual Notes

There are mentions of potential missing information, such as the vaporization temperature of alcohol and the assumption that the cup does not lose heat. Participants also note the importance of units in their calculations.

oldschool
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
got a proplem that i just can't seem to get
200g of water is placed in a 80g aluminum cup and left undesturbed in a freezer until it reaches -5c the cup is then taken out and heated to 96c
a. how much heat is needed to increase the temp (from the -5c to 96c)
b. replace the alum cup with an iron cup of 120g and replace the water with ethyl alcohol how much alcohol is neded to add the same amount of heat as in part A and to raise the temp from -5c to 96c

thanks for any help
john
 
Physics news on Phys.org
a) use the "specific heat" formula: Q = cm delta-T. But use it twice. FInd the total heat (Q_cup + Q_water) for the same change in T.

b) once you have the total Q, set up the same equation as before (except now for the specific heats of iron and alcohol). Use the total Q from part a and solve for the mass of alcohol.
 
so for a it would be Q=(200g)(.5)(-5-0) (to change from ice to a liquid) + (200g)(79.7)(latent heat)+(200g)(1)(0-96)

do i just add on the aluminum q then to that ?

Qalum=(80g)(.22)(-5-96)

looking at it i believe i do just add that on but i would like to make sure I am rite lol
 
Well, you don't simply have to increase the temperature. At 0°C, you have to melt the ice. That will require some amount of kJ/kg. Only have that heat is thrown into the ice, can you start to raise the temperature of the water some more.

So in addition to Qrequired to heat the water and Qrequired to heat the can, you also have Qrequired to melt the ice.
 
oldschool said:
so for a it would be Q=(200g)(.5)(-5-0) (to change from ice to a liquid) + (200g)(79.7)(latent heat)+(200g)(1)(0-96)

do i just add on the aluminum q then to that ?

Qalum=(80g)(.22)(-5-96)

looking at it i believe i do just add that on but i would like to make sure I am rite lol

then for b it would be (assuming the top is correct and i did cacls right it should be 37417.6 cals)

37417.6=(m)(.58)(-5-78)+(m)(25)+(m)(.58)(78-96)

that look correct?
 
oldschool said:
so for a it would be Q=(200g)(.5)(-5-0) (to change from ice to a liquid) + (200g)(79.7)(latent heat)+(200g)(1)(0-96)

do i just add on the aluminum q then to that ?

Qalum=(80g)(.22)(-5-96)

looking at it i believe i do just add that on but i would like to make sure I am rite lol

What you meant to say was

so for a it would be Q=(200g)(.5cal/g.oC)(0-(-5))oC + (200g)(79.7cal/g) (latent heat; to change from ice to a liquid))+(200g)(1cal/g.oC)(96-0)oC

and

Qalum=(80g)(.22cal/g.oC)(96-(-5))oC

oldschool said:
then for b it would be (assuming the top is correct and i did cacls right it should be 37417.6 cals)

37417.6=(m)(.58)(-5-78)+(m)(25)+(m)(.58)(78-96)

that look correct?

Here i assume you are talking about the alcohol, and I will assume you have the constants correct, except for the missing units (we all do that, but we shouldn't) and the temperature values being reversed again (this is what I wanted to call attention to more than the units). Of course you still have to find the heat for the cast iron cup. Plus, there might be a bit of a "trick" to this question. If the cast iron cup is open, how much heat is it going to take to raise the temperature of the cup above the vaporization temperature of the alcohol? Where is the alcohol vapor?
 
Last edited:
OlderDan said:
What you meant to say was

so for a it would be Q=(200g)(.5cal/g.oC)(0-(-5))oC + (200g)(79.7cal/g) (latent heat; to change from ice to a liquid))+(200g)(1cal/g.oC)(96-0)oC

and

Qalum=(80g)(.22cal/g.oC)(96-(-5))oC



Here i assume you are talking about the alcohol, and I will assume you have the constants correct, except for the missing units (we all do that, but we shouldn't) and the temperature values being reversed again (this is what I wanted to call attention to more than the units). Of course you still have to find the heat for the cast iron cup. Plus, there might be a bit of a "trick" to this question. If the cast iron cup is open, how much heat is it going to take to raise the temperature of the cup above the vaporization temperature of the alcohol? Where is the alcohol vapor?


thanks for catching me on the iron cup lol i forgot all about that i saw the proplem of revered temps when i did the equation so i fixed that the vaper point of alcohol is like 118 i think so thankfully i didn't ahve to worry about that and the cup wasn't supposed to loose any heat

thanks for the help though
 
NB:
yes I did forget about the latent heat of ice melting. But someone already caught it. Ah, well.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
21
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 40 ·
2
Replies
40
Views
7K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
5K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K