Thread Closed

Fusion and Fission grail

 
Share Thread
Aug30-05, 05:30 PM   #1
 

Fusion and Fission grail


This may seem like a crazy or stupid question. Maybe both.

What if there was a way to generate fusion using an element like Hydrogen, and then, miraculously, discover a way to generate fission out of the end result (in this case Hellium)? Could the constant fusion-fission between Hydrogen and Hellium end in an endless energy source, or am I thinking of another perpetual motion machine here?
PhysOrg.com physics news on PhysOrg.com

>> Kenneth Wilson, Nobel winner for physics, dies
>> Two collider research teams find evidence of new particle Zc(3900)
>> Scientists make first direct images of topological insulator's edge currents
Aug30-05, 05:56 PM   #2
 
Mentor
Blog Entries: 28
Quote by rpcarnell
This may seem like a crazy or stupid question. Maybe both.

What if there was a way to generate fusion using an element like Hydrogen, and then, miraculously, discover a way to generate fission out of the end result (in this case Hellium)? Could the constant fusion-fission between Hydrogen and Hellium end in an endless energy source, or am I thinking of another perpetual motion machine here?
There is a reason why energy is given out when two light elements fuse, while energy is only given out when a heavy element undergoes fission. Look at the nuclear binding energy curve.

To cause Helium to undergo fission (even if this is possible) REQUIRES energy. It does NOT liberate energy upon such a process. So in principle, even under optimum condition, you're just swallowing up the energy that you generated from the fusion process. So why even bother?

Zz.
Thread Closed

Similar discussions for: Fusion and Fission grail
Thread Forum Replies
Why is fusion stronger than fission? Nuclear Engineering 31
Nuclear Fusion Rockets v.s Fission General Astronomy 38
Fusion vs Fission Introductory Physics Homework 3
[SOLVED] fusion vs. fission General Physics 4
Nuclear Fusion and Fission General Physics 3