Why does light appear to slow down in different mediums?

nautica · Dec 1, 2003

Speed of Light?

Would someone clear up the speed of light? Is it dependent on the medium in which it travels, or not? Depending on what you read. It says that light always travels at "c". Or it can be slowed down "refracted" depending on the medium.

Nautica

sridhar_n · Dec 1, 2003

The speed of light is always a constant irrespective of the frame of reference or medium. The apparent slowing down of light due to refraction is due to the fact that the atoms inside the medium absorb the light and then emit the light after some time delay. This time delay in the transmission of light across the medium gives a feeling that light has been slowed down by the medium!. So as you see, light never travels wit a speed < or > c. It infact travels at c irrespective of where it is headed for, or who makes the measurement, or the medium in which it is traveling in.

Understood?

Sridhar

FUNKER · Dec 1, 2003

so it does not in fact slow down at all? only delayed? then wud tht not be slowing down?

HallsofIvy · Dec 1, 2003

Take your choice. The crucial point of relativity is that the speed of light in vacuum is constant irrespective of the frame of reference.

From a macro point of view, light is slowed down by passing through matter. From a micro point of view, light travels at c from atom to atom and what we perceive as slowing down is the slight delay when light is absorbed and then retransmitted by atoms.

FUNKER · Dec 1, 2003

thanks for that.
but if someone asks me does light slow down in a different medium i say...

sridhar_n · Dec 1, 2003

but if someone asks me does light slow down in a different i say...

... you say that "Yes light is slowed down by the medium as perceived by us at the macro level - However what actually happens is like ...(the previous explanation given that the apparent slowing of light due to delayed transmission of light through the medium) "

Sridhar

FUNKER · Dec 1, 2003

thanks people

turin · Dec 1, 2003

Originally posted by FUNKER
... if someone asks me does light slow down in a different medium i say...

Ask that person what they mean by "light."

HallsofIvy · Dec 2, 2003

And, of course, require that they define "slow down"!

MisterBig · Dec 2, 2003

The reason refraction made sense to me was that as light entered a denser medium its speed decreased and due to its frequency remaining the same the wave length also decreased, balancing the equation c=f.<lambda>. This change in wavelength was then responsible for the change in direction:

$refraction.gif$

Why should refraction exist if the delay is due to light is being transmitted from atom to atom? If this were the case I would expect light to emerge from a medium on a random vector.

turin · Dec 2, 2003

Originally posted by MisterBig
Why should refraction exist if the delay is due to light is being transmitted from atom to atom? If this were the case I would expect light to emerge from a medium on a random vector.

That sounds like a good question to me. My guess would be that, since momentum is conserved, even when a photon is absorbed, the momentum still exists, so there is some preference to emit a photon with that momentum. That's just a guess, though.

Now I got to thinking, about the wavelength. Is the wavelength truly shorter in a higher index of refraction? Or do we just use the shorter wavelength as a pseudo wavelength to do calculations? I guess the first question I should ask: can the light in a refractive medium be coherrent? I've seen laser light in air, but I'm talking about significant refraction. Is laser light coherrent in water?

pallidin · Dec 8, 2003

Originally posted by FUNKER
so it does not in fact slow down at all? only delayed? then wud tht not be slowing down?

Look at it this way: A photon hits a flat piece of glass head on. The photon is absorbed by a particular atom, then after a very brief time, is re-emmited. It is directed to the next atom which does the same thing and so on until it exits the glass.
The photon emmited and re-emmited always is going the speed of light. But, the CUMULATIVE time delay of all the atoms involved in absorption and re-emmission accounts for the apparent, but NOT REAL, slowing down of the photon itself.

Why does light appear to slow down in different mediums?

Similar threads

Undergrad How do I stretch a laser from a beam into a sheet?

Undergrad What areas of maths and physics do I need to understand explosion physics?

Graduate When should I analyze optical problems using ray tracing vs. wavefront analysis?

Undergrad Effective absorption coefficient of gold nanoparticles

High School Fan is pushing in the front and sucking from the back

Insights Thinking Outside The Box Versus Knowing What’s In The Box

Insights Why Entangled Photon-Polarization Qubits Violate Bell’s Inequality

Insights Quantum Entanglement is a Kinematic Fact, not a Dynamical Effect

Insights What Exactly is Dirac’s Delta Function? - Insight

Insights Relativator (Circular Slide-Rule): Simulated with Desmos - Insight

Insights Fixing Things Which Can Go Wrong With Complex Numbers