Recent content by Andrew Mason

  1. Andrew Mason

    Does David Reich contradict Nicholas Wade?

    This graphic from the paper published in Nature in 2015 may help explain the data that Reich was using: The green bars represent the proportion of genes in the populations in the stated country or region added from migrants from the steppe regions of eastern Europe and Asia (Yamnaya); The...
  2. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    So 3 times the fundamental is a harmonic (a twelfth) but not 1.5 (fifth). You might find musicians who would disagree that a perfect fifth is not a harmonic interval. AM
  3. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    The OP was using "overtones" to refer to the sequential harmonics above the fundamental tone. I was just doing the same. I don't think there is a hard an fast rule relating musical terms (overtones) and physics terms (harmonics). AM
  4. Andrew Mason

    Does David Reich contradict Nicholas Wade?

    It depends on whether these statements can be true: 1. "most Europeans are descended from the first settlers who arrived during the Upper Paleolithic Era. " and 2. "Only a minority arrived during the Neolithic age." by Wade and 3. "... just five thousand years ago, the people who are now the...
  5. Andrew Mason

    Viral (RNA and DNA) polymerases, inhibitors and antiviral drugs

    As someone with a long held interest in, but no academic background in, molecular biology, I find this is helpful. I became interested in the idea of using polymerase inhibitors to prevent the SARS-CoV-2 virus from replicating and started this thread in June of 2020 on Remdesivir as well as a...
  6. Andrew Mason

    Does David Reich contradict Nicholas Wade?

    There is a difference, not necessarily a total contradiction. Based on genetic analysis of European skeletons older than 5000 years, inhabitants of Europe before about 3000 BC had mixed genes from hunter-gatherers and Anatolian farmers. Both authors agree on that. Hunter-gatherers arrived in...
  7. Andrew Mason

    Erdos, the Hungarians And other scientists of the era

    It was in 1933, long after Haber's 1918 Nobel prize for making nitrogen fertilizer. The reason, however, is not entirely clear. Rutherford maintained a life-long friendship with Otto Hahn, with whom he worked closely in his Montreal lab. Hahn had worked with Fritz Haber in Germany during WWI...
  8. Andrew Mason

    Finding proper value for centripetal acceleration in a plane rising up

    Yes. But it is not flying level at the bottom portion of the flight path, which is a quarter circle with radius 300m. AM
  9. Andrew Mason

    Finding proper value for centripetal acceleration in a plane rising up

    The question is a bit of a trick question. It says the maximum upward acceleration is 6g. The correct answer is given by ##\vec{a}=-\frac{v^2}{r}\hat{r}=-6\vec{g} ## where the positive direction of ##\vec{a}## is up and that of ##\vec{g}## is down. This results in ##v=132.8 m/s## (assuming...
  10. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    Interesting point. The only opening for sound is the mouth of the pipe and for sound energy to exit there is an acoustic coupling between the standing wave in the pipe and the travelling wave in the external air. As you point out there is a difference between the ambient air pressure outside and...
  11. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    Yes, but the stopped wooden organ pipe does not produce a square wave. I am not suggesting that the physics of musical instruments is simple. But according to all the literature I have found, the fundamental and harmonics of an organ pipe are determined by the length of the pipe and whether...
  12. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    Right. That is how the vibrations originate. So I am confused by your previous reference to "Even harmonics are generated by asymmetrical clipping of the pressure amplitude, like a rectified sinewave. Odd harmonics are generated by symmetrical clipping about zero, like a sinewave with flat...
  13. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    ?? In an organ pipe, the harmonics do not result from clipping sound wave amplitudes. The fundamental and harmonics are generated by resonance within the pipe, which allows standing waves only in discrete multiples of half wave-lengths (open pipe) or discrete odd multiples of quarter...
  14. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    The terms are interchangeable - at least for our purposes. This is a fairly short pipe so there may be some end effects, lip anomalies, or pipe shape effects (e.g. different path lengths permitted within a square shaped pipe) that could be causing this. These would be reduced with a longer...
  15. Andrew Mason

    Undergrad Measured Spectrum of Stopped Wood Organ Pipe Shows ALL Overtones

    A closed pipe with a fundamental frequency of 667 Hz should have overtones of 2001, 3335, 4669 Hz etc corresponding to odd multiples of the fundamental. The open pipe at fundamental 667 Hz should have overtones of 1334, 2001, 2668, 3335, 4002, 4669 Hz. In a wooden pipe, the vibrations in the...