bhobba's latest activity
-
bhobba reacted to martinbn's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
l think the full quote is clearer. -
bhobba reacted to gentzen's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
I think we should be more critical towards people like Niels Bohr (and also John Bell) who insist on never saying or writing anything... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Love.
Only with a very...nuanced...meaning to the word "complete". :wink: I think a better way to describe it would be that Bohr and other... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
That's not quite what it says, although many of its proponents claim that it is. Their claim is based on the particulare interpretation... -
bhobba replied to the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics.It does not imply the reality of the quantum state (nor can it, since QM is wrong). See the original paper... -
bhobba reacted to RUTA's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
Turns out the probabilistic (indeterministic) nature of quantum mechanics (QM) follows from the discrete outcomes. I can't explain all... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Love.
I'm not sure what you mean. But I might be the wrong person to ask, since my own take on QM interpretations is that, while they can be... -
bhobba replied to the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics.Not when looked at carefully. What Bohr and some other adherents did say (unecessaryily IMHO) was it was complete. That Einsten... -
bhobba replied to the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics.That you must interpret QFT - not QM. Art Hobson did that in his book I referenced. While I currently advocate that interpretation... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
No, Copenhagen basically says that we can't even know any "ontology" over and above the probabilistic predictions QM makes for... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
A standard Copenhagen-like interpretation doesn't take any position about what is really happening with "the evolution of the universe"... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
But only if you force the exact same input state each time--which has to include the unobservable particle positions as well as the wave... -
bhobba replied to the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics.The answer is interpretation-dependent. In many worlds, for example, it is fully deterministic. Copenhagen - no. Decoherent... -
bhobba reacted to RUTA's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
Here is a nice explanation of the PBR theorem by Maudlin: He only acknowledges the assumption of statistical independence, so you... -
bhobba reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Help me understand indeterminism in standard quantum mechanics with
Like.
That role is interpretation dependent. In some interpretations, such as the MWI, there is no actual randomness anywhere; everything is...