BillTre's latest activity
-
BillTre reacted to Herman Trivilino's post in the thread What did you do with your old college textbooks? with
Like.
I kept my textbooks for decades because if I wanted to look something up there's no substitute for revisiting a page I learned from... -
BillTre reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered? with
Like.
Invention is a process, not an event. There is no instant of time when an invention "comes into existence". You are trying to draw sharp... -
BillTre replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.No it is not. Its up to you to show how your claim applies to the more realistically observable cases you just agreed to. Making claims... -
BillTre replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.Seems like it is completely a human made up thing. It is not objective that this group existed as a group based on some footprints... -
BillTre replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.These have only been observed indirectly (fossil footprints). It would seem to be more concrete to discuss things that are more directly... -
BillTre reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered? with
Like.
Then at least some prime numbers are discovered--those that appear, for example, in the time periods of cicadas. -
BillTre reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered? with
Like.
I disagree. We conceptualize it in a particular way, but evolution does what it does whether humans conceptualize it or not, and what it... -
BillTre reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered? with
Like.
I don't think your usage is consistent with others in this thread--they appear to me to be using "group" in the direct mathematical... -
BillTre reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered? with
Like.
What about the ways prime numbers show up in "natural" settings? For example, there are 13-year and 17-year cicadas. It is not a... -
BillTre replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.How are you defining a natural group?