Recent content by bushmonk

  1. bushmonk

    Undergrad How many worlds is Many Worlds talking about?

    I am not assuming that the decay takes place only once. Only that I have observational access to one decoherent branch, and in that branch the decay has taken place. The decay in other branches may or may not have taken place. I am far from assuming that the decay only occurs once. But it...
  2. bushmonk

    Undergrad How many worlds is Many Worlds talking about?

    A surprising statement to me. I gather that the amplitude of the un-decayed atom gradually decreases and the amplitude of the various decoherent branches gradually increase with time. This raises a couple of questions: 1. How does MWI set t = 0 for this case. 2. Suppose that at a...
  3. bushmonk

    Undergrad How many worlds is Many Worlds talking about?

    For clarity, consider a very orderly crystal with a single radioactive atom at a specific location. It decays by alpha emission. When the alpha particle is emitted, it disrupts the location of nearby atoms and then comes to rest and forms a stray helium atom. It would seem that there is a...
  4. bushmonk

    Undergrad Why don't we bury Schrodinger's Cat?

    This response captures something of my frustration. My experience is that the path towards a decent amateur understanding of QM is educationally inefficient. Much effort for little understanding. The path is obscured by debris, rabbit trails and sometimes rabbit holes. It would not be a good...
  5. bushmonk

    How do I interact with other PF contributors?

    How do I quote a previous contributor, and comment on the quote. Everyone is doing it. I can reply, but I get the entire contribution as quote. I want to focus on a few select quotes. Where are the instructions on how to do it? Can you reply to more than one contribution in the same reply?
  6. bushmonk

    Undergrad Why don't we bury Schrodinger's Cat?

    I made the original post. Oops. I just revived the cat. A special thanks for those that expounded QM in response whether for or against my post. Here is my understanding. Correct me where I am wrong. I think it is misleading to say that a cat is in a quantum state, for the following reasons...
  7. bushmonk

    Undergrad Why don't we bury Schrodinger's Cat?

    What’s with Schrodinger’s Cat? I seem to be missing something. I keep on hearing about Schrodinger’s cat. Why? Why would anyone think that a cat, alive or dead, is in a quantum state? Every quantum experiment involves a quantum state, subject to the law of superposition, being physically...
  8. bushmonk

    Undergrad Measurement and Thermal Effects Similar?

    The reason for my followup question is that I want to know what quantum mechanics says about why some interactions preserve coherence (and therefore the capacity for interference) and others produce localization. In introductory quantum mechanics, I was taught that the localization occurs when...
  9. bushmonk

    Undergrad Measurement and Thermal Effects Similar?

    1. Is this "correctness" generally acknowledged or is it something peculiar to the Bohmian interpretation. 2. I checked out the Bohmian link. The idea that position is the fundamental measurement seemed reasonable--I haven't come across any other. However I couldn't follow the math and so...
  10. bushmonk

    Undergrad Measurement and Thermal Effects Similar?

    A weak (one photon at a time) beam of laser light strikes a double slit. In case 1 the barrier forming the double slit is a mirror. In case 2 the barrier is flat black. An array of detectors surround the experiment and can detect the photon whether it goes through the slit or is reflected. In...