Dale's latest activity
-
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.Yes, this is all correct. This is not correct. The CoM moves along a straight line in any case, regardless of our choice of center of... -
Dale reacted to A.T.'s post in the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc with
Like.
@gen x might be referring to the instantaneous centre of rotation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant_centre_of_rotation The... -
Dale reacted to russ_watters's post in the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc with
Like.
I'm a mechanical engineer, so I get it: I sometimes find the physicists' view of things to be pedantic. But you need to recognize that... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.The center of rotation certainly can translate. Did you not see the plots that I posted? They show what it means. You can pick any point... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.Because the distance between the primary and the satellite can change. And if they are not both tidally locked then the distance between... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Mechanism of Energy Conservation in Zero-Amplitude Sum of EM Waveforms.Please be aware that personal speculation is not permitted here. There is no part of either classical electrodynamics or quantum... -
Dale reacted to A.T.'s post in the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc with
Like.
But the same applies here: - For mere kinematics, any "center of revolution" is as good as another. - For dynamics, there are choices... -
Dale reacted to jbriggs444's post in the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc with
Like.
So yes, you are talking about the case of two or more objects orbitting one another. In that case we do not have a rigid body and the... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.I think that more important than a label of rotation vs revolution you should focus on rigid vs non-rigid motion. Rigid motion can be... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.You can ask “which center of rotation makes my analysis easiest”. -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.The point is to show that any point can be chosen as the center, if desired. You have freedom to choose the center. You misunderstand... -
Dale reacted to A.T.'s post in the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc with
Like.
Here a more recent and accurate answer by the same poster, already quoted in this thread: It's not about being relative in the sense... -
Dale reacted to A.T.'s post in the thread Undergrad Why do objects always rotate about their centre of mass? with
Like.
We choose to decompose the motion into rotation around CM and translation of CM because it makes the math simpler. You can decompose the... -
Dale replied to the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc.To support this see the plots I posted below -
Dale reacted to A.T.'s post in the thread Undergrad Reference frames, center of rotation, etc with
Like.
You can define it either way. Whatever is more convenient. "Center of rotation" is ambiguous, even if the frame of reference is given...