DaveC426913's latest activity
-
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.I'm not talking about the numbers themselves; I'm talking about "The" prime numbers - i.e. that 13 and 17 are part of a group. The group... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.My distinction is: Discovered: it objectively existed as part of the world before humans came along. Does anyone want to hone that? -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.I'm not using the term "group" in the direct mathematical sense (becaue I think it would get too murky). I'm simply looking at any type... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.Agree. Those are prime, and we see how it got that way. My point here is that nature does not have a "group" of primes that it picks... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.Ergo: this is a philosophical question and is thus in GD. -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.Something that exists distinct from humans. A pack of hadrosaurs might be considered a natural group. Humans did not invent the... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.You just self-corrected. You could "choose any random axioms for your theory", but you don't - and the reason you don't is because... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread What the heck is that thing?.There's pretty hefty mountain in the distance, so I suspect we are looking north from near Hwy 76 or 322. (but it can't be on 76 -... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.Couldn't that be said about any mathematical object or operation? Say, 1+1=2? Or pi? Why pick on the monster group of all things? And... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread What the heck is that thing?.No. It is the centre of a wide area. The poster lives near there (according my investigation. Their address is publicly available... -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.Yup. Although technically, that's a bearing. Same principle, different application. -
DaveC426913 replied to the thread Is mathematics invented or discovered?.What mankind invented was the axle. As fresh points out, there are plenty of circles in the natural world - and even things that roll...
