hokhani's latest activity
-
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.Since ##[H,L^2]=0## we have ##L^2H|l,m\rangle=HL^2|l,m\rangle=l(l+1)H|l,m\rangle##. So, ##H|l,m\rangle## is an eigenstate of ##L^2##...
-
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.##|l,m\rangle## are the common eigenstates of ##L^2## and ##L_z##. Also, ##H## is the free particle Hamiltonian (or any Hamiltonian with...
-
Hhokhani reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L## with
Like.
Not the one you wrote down, no. That describes a particle in a bound state. The angular momentum operators of course can be applied to... -
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.Thanks, I think since ##[H,L^2]=0## we have ##H |lm\rangle = \sum_m {\alpha_m |l,m\rangle}## and since ##[H,L_z]=0## we have ##H...
-
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.Right, I didn't notice the degeneracy. Thanks.
-
Hhokhani reacted to renormalize's post in the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L## with
Like.
It is not true that ##\psi## is a free-particle wavefunction just because ##\hat{H},\hat{L}^2,\hat{L}_z## commute when acting on... -
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.For the free particle the three operators Hamiltonian, ##L^2## and ##L_z## commute togethers. So, it seems that ##\gamma_{3,3}## is also...
-
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.let's look at the problem quite quantum mechanically. The wave function ##\gamma_{3,3}## describes a free particle and so we expect the...
-
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.You know that ##L^2 \gamma_{l,m}(\theta, \phi)=l(l+1)\hbar^2 \gamma_{l,m}(\theta, \phi)## and ##L_z \gamma_{l,m}(\theta, \phi)=m...
-
Hhokhani reacted to Nugatory's post in the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L## with
Like.
Nothing. When QM allows something that is classically forbidden, the explanation is that it isn't really forbidden and the classical... -
Hhokhani reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L## with
Like.
There is no such thing. Quantum mechanics is not classical mechanics. The fact that a state has definite ##L^2## and ##L_z##, which is... -
Hhokhani reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L## with
Like.
I think the OP is confused about models and is using the term "classically forbidden" not to refer to any actually valid physics model... -
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.A far as I know, the root of difference between QM and classical mechanics is in the wave nature of quantum particles. So, to deal with...
-
Hhokhani replied to the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L##.I would like to know what causes in the wave picture that particle to penetrate in the classically forbidden regions?
-
Hhokhani posted the thread Undergrad A deep discrepancy between the classical and quantum models of ##L## in Quantum Physics.Take as an example the quantum state ##\gamma_{3,3}## of angular momentum where ##\vec{L}## makes the angle ##\frac{\pi}{6}## with...