jack action's latest activity
-
jack action replied to the thread On Progress Toward AGI.It is also a far cry from "AGI will inherit the Earth": -
jack action reacted to Grinkle's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Sad.
Fair enough - you've been asking for discussion around this and no one has so far engaged directly on that topic. Maybe its OT for this... -
jack action reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
Yes. She describes feeling anger, satisfaction, desire. She just had no framework within which to understand them. But she had memories... -
jack action reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
I'm skeptical because in the only example of such intelligence that we know exists, we humans, it did not arise from linguistics alone... -
jack action reacted to PeroK's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Skeptical.
I would suggest something weaker. That a (measureable) element of intelligence might arise from linguistics alone. An LLM might have... -
jack action reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
To follow up on this a bit: humans don't learn to interact with the world in non-textual ways by processing text. We have much of those... -
jack action reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
Not current LLMs, because they don't have the other information channels to the world that Helen Keller had. A future AI that did have... -
jack action reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
No, it doesn't. It doesn't even have the concept of the text it processes being "about" anything. That's by design; its designers didn't... -
jack action reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
No, very different from humans, because humans can do lots of things besides produce text. You keep missing this crucial point... -
jack action replied to the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts?.I think we are entering the part of the debate that gives me more concerns than intelligence and whatever it may represent... -
jack action replied to the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts?.But you need sensors and a body you can control to pass this test. -
jack action replied to the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts?."Magic", that is the keyword that hit me in your statement. IMO, thinking LLMs can become aware and conscious by themselves is as magic... -
jack action reacted to russ_watters's post in the thread Is A.I. more than the sum of its parts? with
Like.
I thought we did know why they hallucinate? My understanding: They don't store the training data, they store statistics about the...