Recent content by pasmith

  1. P

    High School Uncertain about part of the Order of Operations, from a formula

    Exponentiation has precedence over multiplication.
  2. P

    Undergrad Is the Cauchy stress tensor really a tensor?

    If ##T : V^2 \to \mathbb{R}## is a rank 2 tensor following Jeevanjee's definition, then for any ##w \in V## we can define a linear map $$ \alpha_w : V \to \mathbb{R} : v \mapsto T(v,w).$$ Now by definition ##\alpha_w \in V^{*}##. Now at least when ##V## is finite dimensional ##V^{*}## is...
  3. P

    Solving an elementary trigonometric equation

    $$n\pi + (-1)^n \frac{\pi}4 - \frac{\pi}3 = n\pi + \frac{\pi}{12} (3(-1)^n - 4).$$ For even ##n = 2m## this is ##2m\pi - \frac{\pi}{12}##. For odd ##n = 2m+1## it is $$(2m+ 1)\pi - \frac{7\pi}{12} = 2m\pi + \frac{5\pi}{12}.$$
  4. P

    Undergrad Best way to numerically solve this system of equations?

    It may be easier to express the first two as $$ (1 - sN_i)(1 - c_i \lambda) + sN_i = 1 - c_i\lambda + sc_iN_i \lambda = 0.$$ Newton's method is actually fairly straightforward here; we can even solve the resulting linear system at design time. If we order the variables as ##(N_1, \dots, N_5...
  5. P

    Undergrad Why solve J(X_k) ΔX_k = -F(X_k) instead of computing J⁻¹(X_k) directly

    That appears to be the only method Excel provides for solving ##Ax = b##. The documentation does not explain what method Excel uses to calculate a matrix inverse, but assuming it is based on the standard LAPACK library it is using LU factorisation with partial pivoting.
  6. P

    Great circle between two points on the Earth's surface

    I would rotate the sphere so that one point is at the north pole (0,0,1). Then ##\theta## is just the colatitude of the image of the second point.
  7. P

    Undergrad Why solve J(X_k) ΔX_k = -F(X_k) instead of computing J⁻¹(X_k) directly

    If ##A## is invertible, then solving ##Ax = b## by Gaussian elimination where ##b## consists of zeros except for a 1 in the ##i##th row will give you the ##i##th column of ##A^{-1}##.
  8. P

    Undergrad Why solve J(X_k) ΔX_k = -F(X_k) instead of computing J⁻¹(X_k) directly

    We don't solve linear systems numerically by finding an inverse matrix; that is incredibly inefficient. Instead we use other methods, like Gaussian elimination or LU decomposition.
  9. P

    Finding the range of k for three real roots of a cubic

    Your working appears to be correct, and I obtained the same result by considering the discriminant of ##f##. What did you do to verify the text answer? According to the text, for ##k = -3##, ##f## should have more than one real root, but according to Wolfram Alpha there is only one real root...
  10. P

    Undergrad Do non-orthogonal coordinate systems mean dependent coordinates?

    Coordinates are independent, whether orthogonal or nonorthogonal. Introducing such a dependency restricts you to a curve or a surface rather than the whole space. Consider the following example. A point on the plane can be written as $$x(\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}},\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}) + y(0,1) = xe_x...
  11. P

    Undergrad Limit behaviour of Fibonacci sequence

    Alternatively, we can also consider that the general solution of ##F_{n+2} = F_{n+1} + F_n## is $$\begin{split} F_n &= A \left( \frac{1 + \sqrt{5}}{2}\right)^n + B\left( \frac{1 - \sqrt{5}}{2}\right)^n \\ &= A \varphi^n + B (-\varphi^{-1})^n \\ &= \varphi^n \left(A + B (-\varphi^{-2})^{n}\right)...
  12. P

    Undergrad Limit behaviour of Fibonacci sequence

    A slight correction is indeed required. From ##a_n \geq 1## we have ##a_n \varphi \geq \varphi ## so that $$ |a_{n+1} - \varphi| \leq \frac{1}{\varphi} |a_n - \varphi|$$ which together with ##\varphi > 1## is sufficient for ##a_n \to \varphi##.
  13. P

    Undergrad Limit behaviour of Fibonacci sequence

    There is a much easier way to arrive at these results. From ##a_{n+1} = 1 + a_n^{-1}## and the definition of ##\varphi## we can obtain $$ a_{n+1} - \varphi = (-1)\frac{a_n - \varphi}{a_n\varphi}.$$ Assuming ##a_n \geq 1## we have ##a_n \varphi \geq \varphi > 1## so that $$ |a_{n+1} - \varphi| <...
  14. P

    Undergrad Why should we need to re-prove theorems that have been proved already?

    So that we understand the proofs, and can satisfy ourselves that they are indeed correct proofs. We don't take other people's word for it in mathematics.
  15. P

    Undergrad Why are these cycles disjoint and of equal length?

    It is a fact of basic group theory that conjugation preserves the order of an element (because conjugation is an isomorphism from a group to itself). The order of a cycle is the same as its length: the identity (generally written as a single 1-cycle) has order 1. a transposition (1 2) has order...