Recent content by PeroK

  1. PeroK

    Some thoughts about self-education

    When do I start relearning all the physics I know? It's true I took some physics as part of my mathematics degree back in the early 1980's, but I remembered very little of that when I started studying physics when I retired ten years ago. Also, when I was a mathematics student, I generally...
  2. PeroK

    Curving of gravitational field lines

    The field lines may be curved when two or more bodies are involved. See here, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_field
  3. PeroK

    B Red shifted tired light doubts

    It's not enough to think something, you have to show that what you think matches the data. When Einstein developed the General Theory of Relativity (GR), he found that a static spacetime was not a possible solution for the entire universe. Space must either be expanding or contracting, but...
  4. PeroK

    Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse

    When I say all the crackpots are working on unification theories, that's not the same as saying all people working on unification theories are crackpots. It's a common logical fallacy to confuse a statement and its converse. That said, the conditional probability that someone is a crackpot...
  5. PeroK

    Physics How to close the gap: From Independent Research to Academic Discourse

    Let's suppose I became an editor and to begin with I took every submission seriously. I would read them fully and give the author a reasonable response. What would happen? I'd get an email back from most, if not all, of the authors explaining why I was wrong and why I was being unreasonable...
  6. PeroK

    I Angular Momentum Vector and Its Magnitude

    I'm not convinced you've understood superposition and the linear algebra that describes them. ##L_z = 0## is a complete description of a state. In this state, there are definite no values for ##L_x## and ##L_y##. In this sense, your "configurations" are not quantum mechanical descriptions...
  7. PeroK

    Hi Folks

    :welcome:
  8. PeroK

    Foundations A rigorous approach to learn Mathematics

    The all-seeing, all-knowing Web suggested this video to me today!
  9. PeroK

    Product of two boosts and then two inverse boosts is rotation matrix

    You could always figure it out for yourself. The Wigner rotation is essentially caused by a convention that underlies the Lorentz Transformation: https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/time-dilation-along-multiple-axes.1012568/#post-6602418
  10. PeroK

    I Antiproton and positron annihilation

    Generally annhiliation is between a particle and its antiparticle. The interaction between an antiproton and a positron would be equivalent to the interaction between a proton and an electron.
  11. PeroK

    I Angular Momentum Vector and Its Magnitude

    In general an expected value does not itself need to be one of the possible values. For example, the expected value of a roll of a standard 6-sided die is 3.5. This comes from a uniform distribution of the numbers 1-6. In this case, you could achieve the expected value of ##\langle L^2_x...
  12. PeroK

    Particle Neutrino Particle Physics Book

    Is this useful? https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0510213
  13. PeroK

    Foundations A rigorous approach to learn Mathematics

    I'm not convinced by this. Introductory books on Abstract Algebra, Number Theory and Real Analysis etc. would cover a lot of general and specific ground. If you study them thoroughly, this will take significant time. Probably a year or two of serious part-time study. Also, such textbooks are...
  14. PeroK

    I A question about the origin of Coulomb's law and point charge divergence

    Coulomb's law breaks down for high-energy scattering. QED predicts this and presents Coulomb's law as a low-energy approximation. Moreover, representing elementary charged particles as point particles with well-defined position and momentum (as per Coulomb's law) cannot be compatible with...