Recent content by pervect
-
P
Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?
A symmetry in math or physics means that something under discussion stays unchanged under a particular transformation. The sort of symmetry is usually given as an adjective, for example "rotational symmetry" means that something is unchanged by rotation. Rotation here is an adjective modifying...- pervect
- Post #82
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?
I would concur with the idea that an operational definition is best. In this case, I would suggest that a ring laser gyroscope is the best tool to operationally measure rotation. Actually, it measures the component of rotation along some specific axis, one needs multiple such devices to detect...- pervect
- Post #80
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Riemann curvature of a metric defined with a coordinate basis
My $.02 and advice to the original poster. ##e_a = e_a{}^I \frac{\partial}{\partial x^I}## is not a coordinate basis, it's something more complicated. I would recommend to the OP is that they first reviewing what a coordinate basis actually is. Rather than relying on PF posters get...- pervect
- Post #30
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Riemann curvature of a metric defined with a coordinate basis
I'm already a bit lost. If one has coordinates x^i, I would expect a coordinate basis e_i to be written as $$e_i = \frac{\partial}{\partial x^i}$$ Thus if we have coordinates {##x^0, x^1, x^2, x^3##} the coordinate basis would be {## \partial / \partial x^0, \partial / \partial x^1, \partial...- pervect
- Post #5
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Could a black hole interior contain an entire universe?
Not in general relativity, but in Einstein Cartan theory there are proposals that are not exactly the same as what you propose, but similar enough to be noteworthy. A somewhat gee-whiz popularization can be found at https://www.aip.org/inside-science/every-black-hole-contains-a-new-universe. A...- pervect
- Post #5
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Photons vs Gravitons
The treatment of light beams I've seen in the past (I think it was and ancient book by Tollman) used null dust to model light beams. I think I've seen other authors do the same, though I don't recall the exact sources. The null dust approximation omits the pressure terms, which are small. A...- pervect
- Post #26
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
High School Einstein equations don't work at large scale?
That's going to be very difficult (if it is possible at all) to reconcile with existing evidence. Specifically, the constancy of the speed of light is well established at this point, and there is no known way to reconcile that with absolute time. My understanding is it's already been proved...- pervect
- Post #97
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Photons vs Gravitons
Energy, momenum, and stress all contribute to gravity in GR. Usually only the first two (energy and momentum) would be used used to model light beams. Stress terms in GR are usually negligible anyway, except for pressure, which in the interior of massive astronomical bodies can be...- pervect
- Post #21
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Comparing the time of two moving clocks
There's a paper that suggest an approach to explaining this problem using space-time diagrams. I like the approach a lot, but I haven't seen it actually work because - so far, at least - nobody on PF who has had an interest in the problem has gone so far as to do the work to draw said diagrams...- pervect
- Post #25
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Graduate Is photon frequency intrinsic or observer-dependent?
The numerical value of the energy of a photon (or for GR, a classical pulse of radiation because the quantum concept of photons is technically outside the classical scope of GR) is observer dependent as others have already noted. But there are a couple of points of interest that lead me to an...- pervect
- Post #15
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Definition of distance in GTR
I would say that the proper distance between the LIGO mirros changes with time when the gravitational wave passes. But, I'd say this is just one possible interpretation of the physics. Probably the biggest issue is how familair you might be with the concept of a metric. Are you familiar with...- pervect
- Post #5
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Simplified Special Relativity: Looking to get roasted on this
The idea that a theory needs to be falsifiable can be traced back to the philosopher Karl Popper. This is about the philosophy of science - while I generally have a personal preference to avoid much of philosphy (which I can trace back to reading Feynamn's essay "Is Electricity Fire") this is...- pervect
- Post #56
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Simplified Special Relativity: Looking to get roasted on this
I was thinking earlier that I should suggest you look at some of the already existing alternate formulations of special relativity. But hearing that your theory is somehow both the same and yet different than the standard formulation makes me wonder if that's going to work out. If the idea...- pervect
- Post #42
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
P
Undergrad Do non-orthogonal coordinate systems mean dependent coordinates?
The language here is confusing. I wouldn't say that changing one coordinate result in changing another coordinate, given that changing a coordinate is defined by holding the other coordinates constant. If you have a 3 dimensional manifold with coordinates p,q, and r, ##\partial / \partial p##...- pervect
- Post #9
- Forum: Differential Geometry
-
P
High School A simple Black Hole question I can't find an answer for
I know Kip Thorne liked the BKL singularity (this was mentioned in his popularization Black Holes and Timewarps), as does Andrew Hamilton (from https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.05292), but I hadn't heard about the numerical simulations. Is the BKL singularity generally accepted as being the likely...- pervect
- Post #30
- Forum: Special and General Relativity