Recent content by shadishacker

  1. S

    I Is the speed of gravitational waves non- dispersive?

    Dear all, In a recent talk, I have heard that speed of gravitational waves is non-dispersive. How is it proved "observationally" in LIGO detections that all the frequencies travel with the same speed, so one can say the speed is non-dispersive?
  2. S

    I The error bars of redshift drift

    Dear all, I am reading the paper "Cosmic dynamics in the era of Extremely Large Telescopes " by Liske et al. about redshift. I get the physical meaning of redshift drift, but when it comes to the error bars, I am confused. - Aren't the error bars given in equation (15) ? - Isn't this function...
  3. S

    I Radial BAO size method and Hubble parameter

    Hi! Can anyone tell me what the radial BAO size method is? how do people use it to get to the H(z)? I am reading the paper "Constraints on the Dark Side of the Universe and Observational Hubble Parameter Data " by Zhang et al. and I think I am lost! Can anyone tell me very simple, how they do...
  4. S

    I Systematic Redshift: Exploring Mg II Uses

    Dear Bandersnatch, Sorry if I marked the level wrong. Anyway, thanks for the explanations. I get the point now.
  5. S

    I Systematic Redshift: Exploring Mg II Uses

    So zero is not smack dab in the middle of the range, but it is -0.01. right? do they conclude the variation is zero because of -0.01 is a small number near 0?
  6. S

    I Systematic Redshift: Exploring Mg II Uses

    Am I missing something? Isn't the middle of the range -0.01?
  7. S

    I Systematic Redshift: Exploring Mg II Uses

    But how this "null result" given in this number? $\Delta \alpha/ \alpha = (-0.01\pm0.26) \times 10^{-5}$ which is for instance given in CONSTRAINING THE VARIATION OF THE FINE-STRUCTURE CONSTANT WITH OBSERVATIONS OF NARROW QUASAR ABSORPTION LINES" by Songaila et. al ? I mean, how is 0 at the...
  8. S

    I Systematic Redshift: Exploring Mg II Uses

    Thanks a lot for the clear reply. I'd like to ask two other questions: - About this variation, in recent papers like " High-precision limit on variation in the fine-structure constant from a single quasar absorption system " by Kotus et. al mention that the measured variation for alpha is...
  9. S

    I Systematic Redshift: Exploring Mg II Uses

    Hi everyone, I am new to observations and observational terms! I am reading the paper "constraining the time variation of the fine-structure constant" by Srianand et. al in the section "constraining alpha with QSO absorption lines" there is a sentence saying "... rest wavelengths of MG II ...
  10. S

    A Chi squared test for data with error

    Dear Chiro, So you mean I can change the shape of the distribution to a nomal one? but is it a right thing to do? I mean if there are observational points, then doesn't this change the data completely?!
  11. S

    A Chi squared test for data with error

    I think it means that the mean is 2. and as the distribution is normal, the \begin{equation} \mu^2=0.1\end{equation} However if the distribution is not normal, then \begin{equation} \mu^2\end{equation} would be different from left and right side of the mean.
  12. S

    A Chi squared test for data with error

    yes, it means it can go from 1.9 to 2.9. But until now, I have used Chi squared test only for normal distributions, which are for instance: \begin{equation}f_i = 2_{0.1}^{0.1}\end{equation} i.e. error in both sides are the same.
  13. S

    A Chi squared test for data with error

    Hi everyone. I am totally new to statistics so my question may or may not be simple! I know that for the data fitting we can do a chi squared test like: \begin{equation} \chi^2 = \Sigma \frac{(f_{data}-f_{model})^2}{(error_{data})^2}\end{equation} So I have been doing this for a while, but now...
  14. S

    A Where to find galaxy mass function observational data?

    Dear all, I am looking for observational data for the number count of galaxy mass function: \begin{equation} dn/dM\end{equation} in terms of redshift and also mass, to compare with theories. I know that I can use HIPASS data (most probably), but as I am new to the field, I have to idea: 1-...
  15. S

    A Different equations for the growth factor

    Hi everyone, I am looking for the correct form of the growth factor in large scale structure. I have found two different equations which I think are not consistent! Can anyone please tell me why it is like this? The first one if from the book "formation of the structure in the universe" Edited...
Back
Top