timmdeeg's latest activity
-
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Like.
That still doesn't help, because the area that needs to be covered in the models being proposed can't be limited to just such areas... -
Ttimmdeeg replied to the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model.Instead, looking for negligible tidal effects one would consider areas far away from gravitational centers like stars and galaxies...
-
Ttimmdeeg replied to the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model.So, if you say "that it (the equivalence principle) only applies locally, over a scale where spacetime curvature is negligible and an...
-
Ttimmdeeg replied to the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model.Such scales refer to Galaxy cluster which as I understand it don't feel isotropic expansion. If we consider them as spacetime patches...
-
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PAllen's post in the thread High School Estimates — True Size of the Universe? with
Like.
You can, but many people have a hard time picturing how this is possible. My suggestion provides a way to picture this that was helpful... -
Ttimmdeeg replied to the thread High School Estimates — True Size of the Universe?.Why can't one simply argue that in an infinite expanding universe the distance between any two comoving objects grows without limit?
-
Ttimmdeeg replied to the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model.Unexpectedly for me this seems a crucial point! PeterDonis and Ibix, many thanks for enlightening comments.
-
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Like.
Not the values of coordinate time ##t##--the values of proper time at that coordinate time ##t## that have elapsed for a comoving... -
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Like.
Of course, because the temperature ratio has to be equal to the ratio of scale factors, and the ratio of scale factors is the ratio by... -
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Like.
No, it's what you should expect of any cosmological model that makes it to the stage of getting published in a peer-reviewed journal. It... -
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Like.
I already answered this in post #2: that expansion factor is an observational fact, which all models must account for. So obviously it's... -
Ttimmdeeg reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Informative.
That immediately makes me question the validity of the paper. The whole point of the equivalence principle, in each of its forms (weak... -
TNo, because they share the notion of a scale factor, and with that the temperature ratio is the same as (actually, the inverse of) the...
-
Ttimmdeeg replied to the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model.So ##t## now isn't special. Now both models predict the same "amount" of accelerated expansion whereby the temperature ratio is 1100. If...
-
Ttimmdeeg reacted to Ibix's post in the thread Undergrad Questioning the timescape model with
Informative.
The point is that the ratio of scale factors is also the ratio of CMB temperatures. At recombination the temperature was about 3000K by...