How can we study the forces involved in a push-up and its variations?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 736 views
Luccas Viana
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
In a push-up, what percentage of body weight is supported by each arm? How does this percentage decrease when performing a knee push-up, with support on the knees instead of the feet?

How does this force vary throughout the different stages of a push-up (that is, when the arms are more extended and when they are more flexed)?

How does this force vary when performing a push-up with the hands supported on a surface higher than the feet? (Consider the height of the support surface)
Relevant Equations
2+2 = 4
I would really appreciate any help with this study. If necessary, I can try to create diagrams to better illustrate the situation described. Please do not hesitate to contact me if anything is unclear or if you need further clarification. English is not my native language, so I kindly ask you to excuse any grammatical errors.

I will present below what I have developed so far:

The human body is modeled as a rigid rod pivoting about a fixed axis located at the foot supports. The mass distribution is concentrated at a single point, the Center of Mass (C), while the reaction force exerted by the hands is applied along the vertical line passing through the Shoulder (S).

Description of the variables

SymbolDescription
HHeight of the person
SHeight of the shoulder
CPosition of the center of mass
WTotal mass of the person
gGravity


Static Equilibrium

For the body to remain in static equilibrium, the sum of all forces and the sum of all moments about any point in the system must be zero:

$$\sum F = 0$$

$$\sum \tau = 0$$

The total gravitational force acting on the Center of Mass is calculated as follows:

$$P = W \cdot g$$

Percentage of Body Weight

The geometric relationship between the position of the Center of Mass (C) and the point where the force is applied at the shoulders (S) determines the exact percentage of body weight transferred to the arms:

$$K_{arms} = \left(\frac{C}{S}\right) \cdot 100$$

Upper Position (Arms Extended)

In the inclined plane configuration at the starting point, the condition for rotational equilibrium about the foot support point yields the following equation:

$$F_{hands} \cdot S - P \cdot C = 0 \implies F_{hands} = P \cdot \left(\frac{C}{S} \right)$$

From this point onward, I have not developed anything further yet.

How does one calculate the fraction of body weight supported by the arms in the lower position, with the elbows bent?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Luccas Viana said:
Homework Statement: In a push-up, what percentage of body weight is supported by each arm? How does this percentage decrease when performing a knee push-up, with support on the knees instead of the feet?

How does this force vary throughout the different stages of a push-up (that is, when the arms are more extended and when they are more flexed)?

How does this force vary when performing a push-up with the hands supported on a surface higher than the feet? (Consider the height of the support surface)

Relevant Equations: 2+2 = 4

I would really appreciate any help with this study. If necessary, I can try to create diagrams to better illustrate the situation described. Please do not hesitate to contact me if anything is unclear or if you need further clarification. English is not my native language, so I kindly ask you to excuse any grammatical errors.

I will present below what I have developed so far:

The human body is modeled as a rigid rod pivoting about a fixed axis located at the foot supports. The mass distribution is concentrated at a single point, the Center of Mass (C), while the reaction force exerted by the hands is applied along the vertical line passing through the Shoulder (S).

Description of the variables

SymbolDescription
HHeight of the person
SHeight of the shoulder
CPosition of the center of mass
WTotal mass of the person
gGravity


Static Equilibrium

For the body to remain in static equilibrium, the sum of all forces and the sum of all moments about any point in the system must be zero:

$$\sum F = 0$$

$$\sum \tau = 0$$

The total gravitational force acting on the Center of Mass is calculated as follows:

$$P = W \cdot g$$

Percentage of Body Weight

The geometric relationship between the position of the Center of Mass (C) and the point where the force is applied at the shoulders (S) determines the exact percentage of body weight transferred to the arms:

$$K_{arms} = \left(\frac{C}{S}\right) \cdot 100$$

Upper Position (Arms Extended)

In the inclined plane configuration at the starting point, the condition for rotational equilibrium about the foot support point yields the following equation:

$$F_{hands} \cdot S - P \cdot C = 0 \implies F_{hands} = P \cdot \left(\frac{C}{S} \right)$$

From this point onward, I have not developed anything further yet.

How does one calculate the fraction of body weight supported by the arms in the lower position, with the elbows bent?
There is a lot of geometry to track if you are trying to be precise? I think I diagram of the free body in certain positions is a great place to start. Then you likely have to make some reasonable assumptions, maybe even a video of yourself completing a pushup is warranted so you can see the geometry in action.
 
Luccas Viana said:
How does this force vary throughout the different stages of a push-up (that is, when the arms are more extended and when they are more flexed)?
Seems like the wrong question. The very start of the push-up is the hardest, but that's to do with torques and arm geometry, not the force exerted by the hands.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: A.T. and PeroK
PeroK said:
Get a pair of bathroom scales and do the push ups on those.
Or just use a pole across a single scale and tare out the weight of the pole. :wink: