Crash sinks a riverboat in New Orleans
- Thread starter BillTre
- Start date
7 replies · 387 views · last reply
Discussion
Science Advisor
2025 Award
- 17,293
- 10,753
Is there a macro version of the Casimir Effect.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect
Science Advisor
- 13,549
- 4,407
Venturi/Bernoulli effects can create lower pressure in flow through a narrow gap between two ships.Baluncore said:Is there a macro version of the Casimir Effect.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect
Science Advisor
2025 Award
- 17,293
- 10,753
It is good to know that a boiler explosion was impossible on the paddle wheel vessel American Heritage.
It was powered by two Caterpillar ACERT diesel engines, that drove a pair of 360-degree rotating Z-drive azimuth thrusters, which gave it a cruising speed to 12 knots and provided manoeuvrability.
Hydraulic pumps on the two main diesel engines, turned a hydraulic motor that drove the stern-mounted paddle wheel.
Three Caterpillar C-18 diesel engines provided auxiliary power for shipboard systems and propulsion support.
It was powered by two Caterpillar ACERT diesel engines, that drove a pair of 360-degree rotating Z-drive azimuth thrusters, which gave it a cruising speed to 12 knots and provided manoeuvrability.
Hydraulic pumps on the two main diesel engines, turned a hydraulic motor that drove the stern-mounted paddle wheel.
Three Caterpillar C-18 diesel engines provided auxiliary power for shipboard systems and propulsion support.
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 2,864
- 12,796
Here is an update video on the collision (actually an illision since one ship was not moving).
More videos. More recent information.
The ship probably did not loss all power, but the helm seemed to be compromised.
Since it occurred in the city of New Orleans (not the train), responders showed up almost immediately, saving many.
More videos. More recent information.
The ship probably did not loss all power, but the helm seemed to be compromised.
Since it occurred in the city of New Orleans (not the train), responders showed up almost immediately, saving many.
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
- 2,912
- 2,370
According to the NTSB, the ship's rudder was stuck in the right rudder position, and according to the above videos, it looks like it was stuck in full right rudder as the turn appears quite sharp. The question remains: why was the rudder in that position, since it was sailing directly upriver, which would usually only require a little right rudder to compensate for the wash of a right-hand propeller?
Also note that the ship was low in the water at the stern compared to the bow, making it easier for a current or wind to help change course to starboard. Also as noted in the second video, there is a propeller wash on the starboard side that is probably due to a right handed prop in full reverse, which further causes the ship to turn to starboard.
When the ship started to turn the rate was 5 deg every 30 seconds, according to the second video. From the start of the turn to the allision, +90 degrees, it took about 2 minutes.
All factors, rudder position, current, and reversing the engine caused the ship to turn to starboard.
In retrospect, could trying to stop the boat have been a bad idea, the only option, or just bad execution?
Also note that the ship was low in the water at the stern compared to the bow, making it easier for a current or wind to help change course to starboard. Also as noted in the second video, there is a propeller wash on the starboard side that is probably due to a right handed prop in full reverse, which further causes the ship to turn to starboard.
When the ship started to turn the rate was 5 deg every 30 seconds, according to the second video. From the start of the turn to the allision, +90 degrees, it took about 2 minutes.
All factors, rudder position, current, and reversing the engine caused the ship to turn to starboard.
In retrospect, could trying to stop the boat have been a bad idea, the only option, or just bad execution?