Could a lightsaber deflect a phaser?

  • Thread starter Thread starter narf0708
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the hypothetical scenario of whether a lightsaber can deflect a phaser, stemming from debates between Star Wars and Star Trek fans. Participants agree that since both weapons are fictional, there is no definitive answer, but the enjoyment of the debate lies in exploring possibilities. A key point raised is that for a fair and engaging fictional fight, lightsabers must be able to deflect phaser blasts, as they are melee weapons while phasers are ranged. This dynamic would prevent a quick resolution to the encounter. Additionally, the conversation touches on the importance of understanding the lore and mechanics established by the creators of each franchise to enrich the debate.
narf0708
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
This came up in one of my frequent Star Wars vs. Star Trek debates with a friend. Can a lightsaber deflect a phaser?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
narf0708 said:
This came up in one of my frequent Star Wars vs. Star Trek debates with a friend. Can a lightsaber deflect a phaser?

Since neither is real, you get to make up your own answer.
 
phinds said:
Since neither is real, you get to make up your own answer.
True, but that's no fun!
 
As phinds says, there's no "right" answer here. We just have to decide which answer is more fun.

A fun fight (in fiction) is a fairer one. Lightsabers are melee weapons, while phasers are ranged. If a lightsaber couldn't deflect a phaser, it would be a really short fight, wouldn't it?

On that basis, I would say, lightsabers "have" to deflect phaser blasts. Whether on stun or kill.

As to the fictitious mechanism (physics) behind it, you can basically pull it out of your rear end. But to be faithful to canon, you need to read more about what the creators of the respective series have published about how their weapons "work".
 

Thread 'Stories about not so soft space fighters'

I wonder how much stories were written, that involve space fighters, and arent so soft as Star wars. I dont think missiles totally make fighter craft obsolate, for example the former cant escort shuttles if one wants to capture a celestial body. I dont insist fighters have to be manned (i enjoyed Enders game about someone control the events for afar) but i also think it isnt totally unjustifiable.
View full post »

Thread 'Dune: Prophecy, what to read for additional story context?'

So far I've been enjoying the show but I am curious to hear from those a little more knowledgeable of the Dune universe as my knowledge is only of the first Dune book, The 1984 movie, The Sy-fy channel Dune and Children of Dune mini series and the most recent two movies. How much material is it pulling from the Dune books (both the original Frank Herbert and the Brian Herbert books)? If so, what books could fill in some knowledge gaps?
View full post »

Similar threads

Can Telekinesis Replace Magnetic Fields in Lightsaber Design?
Replies
1
Views
2K
What does magnetically sealed possibly mean?
Replies
9
Views
2K
Photos from visit to Star Trek exhibit.
Replies
1
Views
2K
Star Wars: How the lightsaber works.
Replies
11
Views
6K
Using a solar mirror to deflect a star
Replies
19
Views
2K
The Potential of Sci-Fi Weapons: Could We Build Them?
Replies
21
Views
4K
Could ball-lightning weapons be feasible in the future?
Replies
6
Views
3K
Could the Star Wars galaxy possibly be a void galaxy?
Replies
12
Views
3K
What kind of telescope can see planets in other galaxies?
Replies
13
Views
3K
How many mSv of radiation would a bolt of ionized plasma deliver?
Replies
6
Views
2K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top