Are Visitors from Outerspace Likely To Be Friendly?

  • Thread starter Mammo
  • Start date
In summary: Perhaps they have a more developed sense of empathy and altruism than us humans.In summary, it is possible that highly advanced visitors from outer space could arrive on Earth in the future. Depending on their level of technology, they may see us as a threat or have no concern at all. It is likely that they would be curious and want to study our planet, but it is also possible that they would want to dominate us for their own needs. It is unknown if there can be altruistic intelligent life, but our current human behavior suggests that dominating tendencies may be common. Contact with these visitors would require tolerance and understanding on both sides.

Are Visitors from Outerspace Likely To Be Friendly?


  • Total voters
    30
  • #1
Mammo
208
0
In the future, it is quite possible that highly advanced visitors from outerspace (HAVO's?) will arrive at our home planet, Earth. Do you think that they will be altruistic and benefit humanity or will they want to dominate humanity for their own needs? Or will they perhaps, only observe us from a distance and not want to make direct contact?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
I'd say it would depend on their level of technology. If theyre not too advanced but still have space travel, we might be a threat to them. However if they are millions of years ahead of us, we would pose no threat at all.

In either case though I would assume that they would be very curious to study the life on our planet (as we would to an alien world) unless again life is very common in the universe and we're the only species that hasn't caught on yet.
 
  • #3
I suspect that if they've advanced to the point where space travel is possible, then they'd have learned to dominate and take advantage of their environmental resources, quite likely to the detriment of other life on their planet (at least initially, showing perhaps some biological/chemical tendency towards aggression/domination). They have probably by that point however also learned that there needs to be some symbiotic balance to maintain these resources, but I suspect that too is done through manipulation. Therefore my vote this morning would be: "they want to dominate humanity for their own needs." I suspect that such "advanced visitors" would also first conduct observation, but later proceed to direct intervention.
 
  • #4
Good point made. But I was assuming that they would be much more highly advanced. I just thought about it a bit, and think that a planet close to developing super-technology could potentially be a future threat. I'm pretty sure that they would be advanced morally as well as by technology. Their home planet would surely be a great distance away. How much of a threat could we be?
 
  • #5
How much of a threat could we be?

Never doubt the ingenuity of the human race. Has Independence Day taught you nothing!
 
  • #6
I'd imagined that they would have transcended their version of humanity into 'super-beings' who have no need for material wants in the way we are familiar with.
 
  • #7
Marxian higher beings? "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need"?
 
  • #8
physics girl phd said:
Marxian higher beings? "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need"?
They could be future Earth Guardians, protecting us from inbound dark comets and asteroids. Super-technology could solve humanity's energy requirements of the future.
 
  • #9
Humanity is proof enough that an intelligent life form in the universe can be the dominating type. We are such a species. Therefore if other intelligent life exists somewhere, then there should be no doubt they can be dominating as well. Because we know this trait works.

What we don't know is whether or not there can be intelligence life out there that is altruistic. We just haven't discovered any.

Perhaps here on earth. Dolphins are very intelligent. And yet they are not so much predatory as laid back.

So my hypothesis is that both models works. And so there should be aliens out there (if exist) that would enjoy destroying this Earth as much as humans enjoy going out on safari.
 
  • #10
I think they will be fat and wear fanny-packs and shorts to our finest restaurants and mispronounce all of our words. We will probably get impatient and they will go back to their planet and say "It's a lovely place to visit, but I wouldn't want to live there."
 
  • #11
waht said:
Humanity is proof enough that an intelligent life form in the universe can be the dominating type. We are such a species. Therefore if other intelligent life exists somewhere, then there should be no doubt they can be dominating as well. Because we know this trait works.
Recent history would seem to provide a counterargument:

The development of weapons capable of destroying all human life on Earth (nuclear weapons) has caused the major powers of the world to stop going to war with each other. This suggests to me that if a species evolves to the point we are at now and survives, it must become at least semi-peaceful. Otherwise, it wouldn't survive the discovery of nuclear weapons.

Similarly, the Earth is becoming saturated with people, yet we are nowhere near the ability to leave permanently. As a result, if we are to survive and prosper past this century, we will need to be able to come into an equilibrium with our environment.
 
  • #12
They can be "altruistic and benefit humanity" "for their own needs".

It depends what are their needs/goals/motives and what kind of threats they are facing.

Mammo said:
Do you think that they will be altruistic and benefit humanity or will they want to dominate humanity for their own needs?

I don't see why they shouldn't/wouldn't consider their needs first.
 
  • #13
How would another species interpret ours? Would they focus on any particular level (individual up to national governmental)? It's hard to know how they would interpret our current wars or local crimes without knowing how they react to their own experiences. Us merely possessing nuclear weapons might be a tad too much to them.

I would expect contact to involve a broad disclosure focusing on our sciences and arts as an attempt to find a middle ground. Tolerance of each others' differences will be paramount to maintaining a successful interspecies' relationship. Great intolerance is still expressed on all levels in many parts of our societies. This could be a useful gauge for approximating a comfort level for possible relations.
 
  • #14
waht said:
What we don't know is whether or not there can be intelligence life out there that is altruistic. We just haven't discovered any. Perhaps here on earth. Dolphins are very intelligent. And yet they are not so much predatory as laid back.
Interesting comment about dolphins. I saw a TV documentary where a group of dolphins showed altruism towards humans by protecting swimmers off the coast of South Africa from the advances of a great white. (Most of the dolphins had shark bite wounds, which showed that this was a group learned ability. I was even envious of their dolphin bravery).
rootX said:
They can be "altruistic and benefit humanity" "for their own needs".
It depends what are their needs/goals/motives and what kind of threats they are facing.
I don't see why they shouldn't/wouldn't consider their needs first.
Would this be such a bad thing? If they wanted to build more spaceships for example, this could still benefit humanity as well. If there was a dark comet heading for Earth and they had the ability to save us, surely this would be a better outcome than natural annihilation?
 
  • #15
DavidSnider said:
I think they will be fat and wear fanny-packs and shorts to our finest restaurants and mispronounce all of our words.

Haha.. one can only hope!
 
  • #16
Another interesting perspective is whether we would be the first planet of advanced intelligent life that they have met. Perhaps they would be prone to making errors of judgement, having nothing to gauge the influence they would have on a new planet. Would they intervene in the event of the outbreak of a nuclear war? If so, would they do this covertly or openly?
 
  • #17
Just ask yourself what we would be like. And if you think we would be good and nice you don't know your history.
 
  • #18
I have no doubt they will be both intelligent and altruistic and will probably find us very tasty and nutritious
 
  • #19
Considering the vast quantities of anti-alien propoganda the media has distributed, they would have to assume we already view them as enemies
 
  • #20
Office_Shredder said:
Considering the vast quantities of anti-alien propoganda the media has distributed, they would have to assume we already view them as enemies
I couldn't agree more. Steven Spielberg made an intelligent start with 'close encounters' but it's gone down hill ever since.
 
  • #21
Its not what visitors from outer space will be, it's how we will react to them that's more certain. Look at human history.
 
  • #22
What if they are 5-D, and that their motives are beyond human comprehension?:confused:
 
  • #23
I think it's a big mistake to equate advanced technology with advanced beings. We humans have developed some amazing technology, especially in the last 100 years or so, but as a species we have not developed any additional capabilities for empathy, generosity, cooperation, etc. In fact, it seems to me that people who are living in primitive societies and/or what most of us would consider poverty value those qualities more than the wealthy and powerful. Why should we expect aliens to be any different?

If their culture causes them to value the rights and lives of all creatures (including us) and they were coming here merely for the sake of exploration, that would be a good thing, but if their forays here were driven by expansionism and a search for resources, it might not be pretty.
 
Last edited:

1. Are there any scientific theories that suggest visitors from outerspace are likely to be friendly?

There are several scientific theories that suggest the likelihood of friendly visitors from outerspace. One theory is the "Zoo Hypothesis" which proposes that advanced alien civilizations are observing us without making direct contact in order to allow us to develop on our own without interference. Another theory is the "Contact" theory, which suggests that any advanced alien civilization would have evolved to be peaceful and cooperative in order to survive.

2. What evidence do we have of friendly interactions with extraterrestrial beings?

There is currently no conclusive evidence of friendly interactions with extraterrestrial beings. However, there have been reported sightings and encounters with UFOs and extraterrestrial beings, some of which have been described as peaceful and non-threatening. However, these reports are often anecdotal and lack solid evidence.

3. What are the potential risks of interacting with visitors from outerspace?

The potential risks of interacting with visitors from outerspace are largely unknown and speculative. Some scientists and experts warn that making contact with extraterrestrial beings could lead to unintended consequences and potential threats to our planet and civilization. It is also possible that advanced alien civilizations may not have the same morals and values as humans, which could lead to conflict or misunderstandings.

4. How likely is it that we will encounter friendly visitors from outerspace in the near future?

The likelihood of encountering friendly visitors from outerspace in the near future is currently unknown. While there have been numerous reported sightings and encounters, there is no concrete evidence to suggest that we will make contact with extraterrestrial beings in the near future. However, with the advancements in technology and space exploration, the potential for contact may increase in the coming years.

5. What steps are being taken by scientists to prepare for potential interactions with visitors from outerspace?

There are ongoing efforts by scientists and organizations to prepare for potential interactions with visitors from outerspace. Some of these efforts include the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI), which aims to detect and analyze radio signals from outer space, and the Messaging Extraterrestrial Intelligence (METI), which attempts to send messages to potential extraterrestrial civilizations. Additionally, many scientists and experts are working to develop protocols and guidelines for potential contact with extraterrestrial beings.

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
879
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
6
Views
540
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
21
Views
1K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
21
Views
852
Back
Top