B Can a fireplace be used as a fallout shelter?

  • B
  • Thread starter Thread starter Mike S.
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Radiation shielding
AI Thread Summary
Using a fireplace as a fallout shelter raises concerns about its effectiveness against radiation, particularly due to vulnerabilities like the damper and the open front. While masonry may provide some protection, it is insufficient compared to the ideal shelter, which should be buried under at least two feet of dirt. The discussion reflects anxiety over nuclear threats, particularly in light of geopolitical tensions, and questions whether cramped quarters in a fireplace are worth the risk during an initial radiation exposure. The conversation also touches on the potential for long-term contamination of food and water sources following a nuclear event. Ultimately, using a fireplace as a shelter is not recommended for serious fallout protection.
Mike S.
Messages
90
Reaction score
32
In 2020 we wondered if we could use socks as filter masks. In 2021 we wondered if we could use Chromebooks as computers. And in 2022...

But seriously, fallout shelters are supposed to protect against "skyshine", gamma rays from disintegrating isotopes in a Doomsday Shroud in the atmosphere. Ideally, you dig under two or more feet of dirt, but if you don't happen to be a loony doomsday prepper and now tomorrow's weather is rain with a chance of falling H-bombs...

I'm thinking the masonry ought to offer some protection. The damper is a vulnerability - almost certainly hit you with some kind of brehmsstrahlung from radiation from directly overhead. But is that enough to matter? And then of course there's the hole in the front, which has view of a lot of horizon.

All told, is decamping to the fireplace to wait out the initial radiation going to be worth suffering the cramped quarters for the last few days of your life?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Mike S. said:
In 2020 we wondered if we could use socks as filter masks. In 2021 we wondered if we could use Chromebooks as computers. And in 2022...

But seriously, fallout shelters are supposed to protect against "skyshine", gamma rays from disintegrating isotopes in a Doomsday Shroud in the atmosphere. Ideally, you dig under two or more feet of dirt, but if you don't happen to be a loony doomsday prepper and now tomorrow's weather is rain with a chance of falling H-bombs...

I'm thinking the masonry ought to offer some protection. The damper is a vulnerability - almost certainly hit you with some kind of brehmsstrahlung from radiation from directly overhead. But is that enough to matter? And then of course there's the hole in the front, which has view of a lot of horizon.

All told, is decamping to the fireplace to wait out the initial radiation going to be worth suffering the cramped quarters for the last few days of your life?
Against the blast if you are far enough away from a major city but then what?
Is this because of Ukraine? Russia have about 7000 nuclear weapons, 7800? It's enough to annihilate the infrastructure of everything you have become accustomed to.
Let's hope this situation (which I have not commented on) either de-escalates or settles down to some sort of civil/guerilla war without nuclear involvement.
Not so great for that country unfortunately.
Edit. It is in the middle of the house so if you are far enough away and protected all the rest of the house then why not.
If you can find this on line I recommend it.

 
Last edited:
I was only thinking of the initial period of "skyshine", not long term contamination of water & food sources. Humans are made out of meat ... maybe the Russians will send us food?
 
Is it April 1st already?
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes russ_watters, berkeman, nsaspook and 1 other person
 
Not recommended ...
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
I wasn't suggesting using the top of the chimney, nor seeking sanctuary at the North Pole. Though having some lady stuck in the opening could help to keep fallout-laced rain from coming in and dripping through the damper.
 
Thread is done.
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top