Jack21222
- 209
- 1
The next series of Doctor Who airs today. Comes on BBC America 9pm Eastern time. Who's watching?
The discussion revolves around the premiere of the new series of Doctor Who, focusing on the introduction of a new companion and the implications of time travel within the show's narrative. Participants explore theories regarding character relationships and memory, as well as the potential for plot misdirection.
Participants do not reach a consensus on the nature of Oswin's memories or the implications of her relationship with the Doctor. Multiple competing theories are presented, and the discussion remains unresolved.
Participants express uncertainty about the timeline and character interactions, highlighting the complexity of memory and identity in the context of time travel. There are references to specific plot points and character arcs that may influence interpretations.
The Doctor said:People assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect, but actually - from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint, it's more like a big ball of wibbly-wobbly... timey-wimey... stuff.
Insanity said:I assume at some point prior to these events, at some point in Oswin's past, The Doctor finds/meets her again in his future. He wouldn't necessarily recognize her as her appearance was that of a Dalek. Might pick up on the voice as I assume her voice over the speakers was her's vs. the Dalek voice when seeing her as the Dalek.
Insanity said:I assume at some point prior to these events, at some point in Oswin's past, The Doctor finds/meets her again in his future. He wouldn't necessarily recognize her as her appearance was that of a Dalek. Might pick up on the voice as I assume her voice over the speakers was her's vs. the Dalek voice when seeing her as the Dalek.
It is possible that those memories were excised during her "Dalekfication". Or it could just come down to "Timey Wimey stuff".Darwin123 said:Then why doesn't Oswin remember the Doctor?
Of course, maybe the Doctor will have regenerated before he meets Oswin. Then, it is possible that they won't remember each other.
However, even that doesn't work precisely. She looked up the Doctor on the Dalek data base. If she had been a Companion, then she would have remembered being a Companion of some incarnation of the Doctor.
Janus said:It is possible that those memories were excised during her "Dalekfication". Or it could just come down to "Timey Wimey stuff".