The forum discussion centers on the existence and movement of quantum entities, specifically addressing Neils Bohr's assertion regarding the quantum world. Participants emphasize that the uncertainty principle does not negate the existence or movement of quantum objects such as protons, electrons, and photons. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding basic physics and the role of mathematics in describing natural phenomena, rather than relying solely on mathematical interpretations. Ultimately, the discussion concludes that the quantum world is populated with various entities that do indeed exist and move, contrary to some misconceptions.
PREREQUISITESPhysics students, quantum mechanics enthusiasts, and anyone interested in the foundational concepts of quantum theory and its implications on the nature of existence and movement in the micro world.
What does that even mean? The "quantum world" is just a description of things very small, all of which do LOTS of things. Ever heard of electricity? An electron is a quantum object.DiamondHead said:
I was looking for a scientific answer specifically one related to quantum theory.phinds said:
Math does not say what exists. NATURE says what exists. Where possible, we use math to describe what nature creates. Do you think electrons do not move?DiamondHead said:
phinds said:
Protons, neutrons, photons, electrons, neutrinos ... Do you not know how to use Google?DiamondHead said:
The uncertainly principle has nothing to do with whether or not things exist and whether or not they move.DiamondHead said:
Ummmm.... atoms, nuclei, a large number of subatomic particles, just to list the obvious Physical things. Then there are fields, energy, momentum, spin, etc, etc. Pretty much everything you're likely to have been taught exists. Why would you doubt it?DiamondHead said:
topsquark said:
I think you need to think more deeply about the uncertainty principle.phinds said:
phinds said:
phinds said:
