"Engine fuel consumption map" without the torque possible?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the challenge of creating an engine fuel consumption map without direct measurements of engine torque. Participants explore whether torque can be derived from available data, particularly focusing on the OBD_Calculated_engine_load_value and other vehicle parameters.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant seeks to derive engine torque using various vehicle parameters, as the actual torque measurement is unavailable.
  • Another participant asserts that calculating torque requires a formula that includes torque, referencing the relationship between torque, engine speed, and mechanical power.
  • A participant notes that the power of the car is not measured during tests, only documented values are available.
  • There is a suggestion that it may be possible to estimate power using other values like vehicle speed, road incline, and air density, though this would require experimental input.
  • One participant references a source indicating that the OBD_Calculated_engine_load_value represents the percentage of available peak torque.
  • Another participant acknowledges the indication of peak torque but points out a poor correlation in the data presented.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the feasibility of deriving torque from the available data, with no consensus on the methods or formulas that could be applied. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best approach to estimate engine torque.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the reliance on indirect measurements and the absence of a clear formula for calculating torque from the available parameters. The discussion also highlights the potential need for experimental validation of proposed methods.

joker1319
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hello,
I am currently facing a problem.
I'm on a project and trying to create an "engine fuel consumption map (engine torque / engine speed)" among other things. Unfortunately, the engine torque is not measured in my measurements. More specifically, the "actual engine - percent torque (OBD PID 98)" outputs only "-125".

Therefore, I wonder if it is possible to derive the torque (approximately) with the following information I have:
  • Velocity GPS km/h
  • Velocity ECU km/h
  • Engine Speed rpm
  • Ambient Temperature degC
  • Relative Humidity %
  • Ambient Pressure kPa
  • GPS Altitude m
  • Altitude Amb, Pressure m
  • Exhaust Temperature degC
  • Exhaust Mass Flow g/s
  • Exhaust Volume Flow (1atm 20degC) m3/s
  • Coolant Temperature degC
  • Intake Manif, Pressure Abs kPa
  • Intake Manif, Pressure Rel kPa
  • Intake Manif, Temperature degC
  • Oil Temperature degC
  • Throttle Position %
  • Intake Mass Flow g/s
  • OBD_Accelerator_Pedal_Position_D_(PID_73) %
  • OBD_Ambient_air_temperature_(PID_70) °C
  • OBD_Barometric_pressure_(PID_51) kPa
  • OBD_Calculated_engine_load_value_(PID_4) %
  • OBD_Commanded_throttle_actuator_(PID_76) %
  • OBD_Control_module_voltage_(PID_66) V
  • OBD_Relative_throttle_position_(PID_69) %
  • OBD_Run_time_since_engine_start_(PID_31) s
  • va m2/s3
  • va_pos m2/s3
  • Acceleration m/s²
  • m_CO2 g
  • m_CO g
  • m_NOx g
  • n_PN -
  • y_CO2 %
  • y_CO ppm
  • y_NO ppm
  • y_NO2 ppm
  • y_NOx ppm
  • y_O2 %
  • ndot_PN #/s
  • mdot_CO2 g/s
  • mdot_CO g/s
  • mdot_NO g/s
  • mdot_NO2 g/s
  • mdot_NOx g/s
  • mdot_O2 g/s

Some people claim that with the "OBD_Calculated_engine_load_value" somehow the engine torque can be derived. Unfortunately I have not yet found the formula of "Calculated_engine_load" which does not include the torque.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
joker1319 said:
Unfortunately I have not yet found the formula of "Calculated_engine_load" which does not include the torque.
Huh? If you want to calculate torque you need a formula with torque in it.

Engine torque * engine rpm * 2 pi/minute = engine mechanical power
The 2 pi/minute is converting rpm to an angular velocity. You have rpm, if you have the mechanical power of the engine you get torque.
 
The problem is that the power of the car is not measured. It is only the power according to the vehicle documents known, but not the currentl power during the test.
 
What is OBD_Calculated_engine_load_value_(PID_4) then?

It is possible to estimate the power based on other values, like the speed of the car, the incline of the road, the density of air and some car-specific constants, but that will probably need experimental input.
 
CWatters said:
According to this..

http://obdcon.sourceforge.net/2010/06/about-pid-calculated-load-value/

It indicates the percentage of available peak torque.
1Wj900B.png


i know that it indicates the percentage of available peak torque...but when you look at the pic you will see that the correlation of them is pretty poor
 

Attachments

  • 1Wj900B.png
    1Wj900B.png
    32.1 KB · Views: 604
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

Replies
25
Views
4K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
6K
Replies
14
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
8K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
10K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
15K