If you wear glasses please look at this picture optical illusion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hxtasy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Optical Picture
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around an optical illusion experienced by some participants while viewing a computer-generated image, particularly when wearing glasses. The conversation explores the effects of different types of lenses and monitors on the perception of the illusion, as well as the phenomenon of chromatic aberration.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Debate/contested, Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes experiencing a significant optical illusion that appears to shift when viewed through their glasses, suggesting it may be related to the coloration of pixels and the properties of their polycarbonate lenses.
  • Another participant speculates that the monitor setup could be influencing the perception of the illusion, mentioning the possibility of oblong-shaped pixels.
  • Several participants report not experiencing the illusion at all, indicating that it may be specific to certain types of glasses or monitors.
  • A participant explains chromatic aberration as a potential cause of the perceived shifting, detailing how different wavelengths of light can separate and affect vision, particularly at the edges of objects.
  • Another participant notes that they see the blue hexagons move significantly with head movement, attributing this to their high-index lenses.
  • Some participants express confusion about the extent of the shift, with one noting it appears to move about an inch when viewed alongside a finger.
  • Humor is introduced when one participant suggests that those without glasses should take LSD to experience the illusion, highlighting the subjective nature of the phenomenon.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally do not agree on the experience of the optical illusion, with some seeing it and others not. Multiple competing views exist regarding the causes of the perceived effects, particularly concerning the role of glasses versus monitor characteristics.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various types of glasses and monitors, which may influence the perception of the optical illusion. There is also a discussion about the effects of lighting conditions, such as fluorescent lighting, on the experience.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in optical illusions, vision science, or the effects of different lens types on perception may find this discussion relevant.

hxtasy
Messages
112
Reaction score
1
While drawing a computer chassis I'm designing, i came across a really weird optical illusion. it only seems to work with my glasses on. i put sun glasses on and could see it move a little, but with classes if you stare at the hexagons and move your head while looking at them, everything shifts, not just a little like a full inch back and fourth.

if you zoom in a lot it still does it. i think it's the coloration of the pixels and how my glasses (polycarbonate lens no anti glare coating) reflect the different colors, making it appear to shift. I can't figure it out completely and its making me trip balls.

i'm in a fluorescent lit room if it makes a difference.

does anyone else with glasses see this?

opticalillusionhexagonswtf.jpg
 
Physics news on Phys.org
on second thought it could have something to do with the way my monitor is set up. samsung LED monitor, maybe it has oblong shaped pixels that look different from a different angle. freaking me out either way.
 
Yeah, its not doing anything to me. It's probably your monitor.
 
yeah, the blue ones (hexagon and the rectangle) moves with my head while others stay still. doesn't work without glasses, my monitor is a cleap TN viewsonic
 
I wear glasses, see nothing happening.
 
wukunlin said:
yeah, the blue ones (hexagon and the rectangle) moves with my head while others stay still. doesn't work without glasses, my monitor is a cleap TN viewsonic

What he/she said, except for the part about the monitor (because I don't have that kind of monitor).
 
No, nothing.
 
It is not your monitor, it's your glasses.

In most glass, the index of refraction is not the same for all wavelengths of light. White light tends to break up into many different wavelengths, just like shining a white beam of light through a prism. This phenomenon is known as "chromatic aberration," and causes no end of headaches for designers of camera lenses.

You can observe chromatic aberration from your glasses in more ordinary circumstances if you pay attention. Hold up a piece of white paper (under reasonably-white light) and look at the edge of the paper while turning your head side-to-side. You should see the left edge appearing blue while the right edge appears yellow, or vice versa, depending on which way you've turned your head. The more you turn your head, the more pronounced should be the effect.

The reason this happens is that the image of the white paper is being split into several images of different colors. Bluer images shift one direction, while more red/yellow images shift the other direction. Most of these images overlap, so you see mostly a white sheet of paper. But near the edges, some of the images do not fully overlap, allowing you to see the individual color.

In your computer drawing, the blue hexagons are a pure shade of blue, so there is no yellow image to shift in contrary motion to the blue. Hence all you see is that the blue moves back and forth. If you look closely at the grey band on the left, you should also see a fringe of either blue or yellow appear as you turn your head.
 
I see nothing happening with and without my glasses, with and without zooming, with and without looking through the part of my lenses with the most chromatic aberration.
My monitor is also a LCD, LG.
 
  • #10
ok for those of you without glasses, i don't want this to be unequal because of you're from a "superior visioned species" so you will have to take a hit of LSD, wait 42 seconds, and retry.
 
  • #11
Ben Niehoff said:
It is not your monitor, it's your glasses.

In most glass, the index of refraction is not the same for all wavelengths of light. White light tends to break up into many different wavelengths, just like shining a white beam of light through a prism. This phenomenon is known as "chromatic aberration," and causes no end of headaches for designers of camera lenses.

You can observe chromatic aberration from your glasses in more ordinary circumstances if you pay attention. Hold up a piece of white paper (under reasonably-white light) and look at the edge of the paper while turning your head side-to-side. You should see the left edge appearing blue while the right edge appears yellow, or vice versa, depending on which way you've turned your head. The more you turn your head, the more pronounced should be the effect.

The reason this happens is that the image of the white paper is being split into several images of different colors. Bluer images shift one direction, while more red/yellow images shift the other direction. Most of these images overlap, so you see mostly a white sheet of paper. But near the edges, some of the images do not fully overlap, allowing you to see the individual color.

In your computer drawing, the blue hexagons are a pure shade of blue, so there is no yellow image to shift in contrary motion to the blue. Hence all you see is that the blue moves back and forth. If you look closely at the grey band on the left, you should also see a fringe of either blue or yellow appear as you turn your head.

thanks, i thought it was something to this effect. but, what i don't get though (not sure if you can see the effect or not) is how far the blue box actually moves, i can see turning a different shade, but it looks like it shifts about an inch, i will hold my finger next to it and it will shift into my finger. really weird.
 
  • #12
i see the blue ones move as i turn my head left or right. it's a pretty big shift, too, but I've also got the thin, high-index-of-refraction lenses, too. neat trick.

speaking of this, i guess it might also explain why i loathe the combination of Blue/Red or Blue text on Black background on web pages. it feels like it makes my eyes vibrate.
 
  • #13
hxtasy said:
does anyone else with glasses see this?

Woooaaaahhhhh! :bugeye:
 
  • #14
Mépris said:
No, nothing.

Same. With or without glasses. And I almost always see whatever optical illusions are supposed to make you see.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K