# Interesting Physics Riddle I Devised

• DifferentialGalois
In summary, the astrophysicist is absentmindedly working through papers on Mossbauer spectroscopy, eventually coming to the Pound Rebka experiment, a remarkable test of GR. The combinatorial geometer is selling vodka, but the physicist takes a sip of his quark soup and places his head outside the window when he notices that the combinatorial geometer is selling bottles of vodka. When he quoth, "I expect that the quantity is some Catalan number. I regret to inform you that I've quite enough of combinatorics for a lifetime," the combinatorial geometer beams briefly but not for too long as the resident of the abode becomes exasperated. The professor emits a gamma ray, causing the
DifferentialGalois
A theoretical astrophysicist was absentmindedly working through papers on Mossbauer spectroscopy, eventually coming to the Pound Rebka experiment, a remarkable test of GR. (Gamma rays were sent from the top of a building to a receiver, so as to measure the gravitational blueshift in such an experiment). Deeply immerse in a physics textbook, it takes the professor a while to realize that outside his cottage, a delivery truck is parked.

"Vodka dlya prodazhi. Zdravstvuyte! Prodazha odnogo funta za butylku!"
"Vodka for sale. Hello! Selling one pound per bottle!"
The words come from a mathematician specialising in combinatorial geometry, albeit struggling to gain a working salary from it and thus, working in food delivery services.

The physicist takes a sip of his quark soup, and places his head outside the window. When he notices that the combinatorial geometer is selling bottles of vodka, he quoth, "I expect that the quantity is some Catalan number. I regret to inform you that I've quite enough of combinatorics for a lifetime."

The combinatorial geometer beams briefly, but not for too long as the resident of the abode becomes exasperated.

The astrophysicist professor emits a gamma ray, causing the delivery truck man combinatorial geometer to dash away at tachyonic velocity. "That lad ought to be five years old."

1. Why does the geometer beam briefly at the mention of the Catalan number? What relevance does the Catalan number have?
2. Within propinquity of the end, the professor states that the geometer's mental age is five. Propose a reason as to why this is the case.

Among Catalan numbers C3 = 5 is unique as being both Odd and Prime.

Last edited:
Why does the geometer measure a bottle of vodka by weight (one pound) instead of by liquid volume (liter or quart)? Pretty sure you are not referring to Pounds Sterling as cost per bottle.

"Beam" in English has many different meanings but you ambiguously use "beam":
• smile (verb)
• transmit electromagnetic radiation and/or particles (verb)
• the transmitted object -- radiation a/o particles; e.g., gamma ray beam (noun)
The astrophysicist is only reading papers not conducting gamma ray experiments. I presume her "beam" is also a smile and the vodka seller's departure speed simile?

[Edit: I caught the reference to Robert Pound and the use of Iron lattices used in that experiment and latices formed by Catalan numbers; but that experiment verified Relativity.]

Robert Pound has no relation to "funta" in Russian that I can detect; nor pound-as-weight to geometry. I distantly remember a joke about the Doppler effect and a street vendor...

Last edited:
Interesting interpretation, with some aspects mentioned in your answer quite different to my original no
tion. Hint: Consider alphabetical shift.

DifferentialGalois said:
Interesting interpretation, with some aspects mentioned in your answer quite different to my original no
tion. Hint: Consider alphabetical shift.
I see it now, I think; quite clever. One of the times I encountered Catalan numbers at work was while matching sub-strings in character arrays and also for parentheses checks.

I have an anecdote about 'rune shifts' in artificial languages but do not want to divert your thread. Thanks, though. I have been contemplating Perfect numbers all morning in relation to Mersenne numbers thanks to researching your Catalans. Also combinatoric geometry is a fascinating idea.

Since you have an entire thread I wrote a riddle/joke:

What language should we use to program Catalan numbers?
LISP
If you have to explain a joke, then it is not funny. Since this joke is not very funny, I better explain, right?
Catalan also refers to the language spoken in Catalonia where people often speak with a lisp.

## 1. What is the riddle about?

The riddle is about a unique physics scenario that requires logic and critical thinking to solve.

## 2. Is it a difficult riddle?

It can be challenging for some, as it involves applying certain principles of physics. However, with careful analysis and problem-solving skills, it can be solved.

## 3. How long does it take to solve the riddle?

The time it takes to solve the riddle varies depending on the individual's knowledge of physics and problem-solving skills. It could take a few minutes to several hours.

## 4. What makes this riddle interesting?

This riddle is interesting because it combines physics concepts with a creative scenario, making it both challenging and thought-provoking. It also encourages critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

## 5. Is this riddle useful for learning physics?

Yes, this riddle can be a fun and engaging way to apply and reinforce physics concepts. It can also help improve critical thinking skills and problem-solving abilities, which are essential in the field of science.