Noodling: Catfishing with Your Bare Hands

  • Thread starter Thread starter Evo
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the practice of "noodling," a method of catching catfish using bare hands. Participants share personal anecdotes, opinions on the dangers and experiences associated with noodling, and comparisons to other forms of fishing and hunting.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants describe noodling as a risky and adventurous way to catch catfish, often associated with rural or impoverished backgrounds.
  • There are personal stories shared about noodling experiences, including one participant's father-in-law who practiced it as a child in Nebraska.
  • Some participants express disbelief at the size of catfish, suggesting that they thought catfish were small, while others assert that they can be quite large and dangerous.
  • A comparison is made between noodling and other extreme activities, such as hunting whales or sharks, with varying opinions on the bravery required for each.
  • One participant recounts a story about a python-catching experience that parallels the bravery involved in noodling.
  • There is a humorous suggestion about having a hunting season for manatees, with some participants expressing disdain for the animal.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally share a sense of adventure regarding noodling, but there are competing views on the dangers involved and the size of catfish. The discussion also includes differing opinions on the ethics of hunting certain animals, such as whales and manatees, indicating unresolved disagreements.

Contextual Notes

Some statements reflect personal anecdotes and subjective opinions, which may not represent broader perspectives on noodling or fishing practices. The discussion includes humor and hyperbole, particularly regarding the comparison of different hunting methods.

Who May Find This Useful

Readers interested in fishing techniques, outdoor adventures, or cultural practices related to food sourcing may find this discussion engaging.

Evo
Staff Emeritus
Messages
24,032
Reaction score
3,277
Our new instructor at work is an absolute hoot. :biggrin: The other day he was telling us about being talked into going "noodling". Knowing him, it might have been true.

For those of you that don't know, "noodling" is a way of catching catfish that's mostly been practiced by hicks & hillbillies but has caught on with other less than intelligent groups of people.

To "noodle", you wade into a shallow area of a river and start groping around underwater for holes that a catfish might hide in. You use only your bare hands. When you feel what you think is a catfish biting down on your hand, you pull whatever it is out of the hole with all your strength and hope that you still have all of your fingers afterwards (which isn't always the case). Sometimes it's a snake or other nasty critter. :bugeye:

Here are some pictures of some successful noodlers and their catch. I think this would be a fine PF event. :-p
 

Attachments

  • noodling2.jpe
    noodling2.jpe
    8.7 KB · Views: 628
  • Noodling3.jpe
    Noodling3.jpe
    31.3 KB · Views: 695
  • otw_fish2.jpe
    otw_fish2.jpe
    10.4 KB · Views: 614
Physics news on Phys.org
ive heard of noodling before...some PBS show i think
 
I'm going to guess "noodling" was discovered by a flyfisherman or canoist who dropped something. I bet they still have nightmares.
 
that looks awsome.
 
Smurf said:
that looks awsome.

My father in law tells me stories about when he was a kid. He was born and razed in Nebraska and his family was very poor. They used to have to hunt and fish just to survive. Anyhow, he used to go noodling as a kid.
 
Townsend said:
He was born and razed in Nebraska...
Cut down before he had a chance.
 
Wow, Townsend I can't imagine having to do this to eat. Your father in law has a lot of guts.

Those things are freeking enormous! And it's dangerous. I thought catfish were small.

How'd you like to fry one of those up?
 
Evo said:
Wow, Townsend I can't imagine having to do this to eat. Your father has a lot of guts.

Those things are freeking enormous! And it's dangerous. I thought catfish were small.

I doubt they ever caught any fish that size...
 
zoobyshoe said:
Cut down before he had a chance.
:smile:...
 
  • #10
Evo said:
Those things are freeking enormous! And it's dangerous. I thought catfish were small.
We used to catch them when I was a kid in N.H. and there, they were small. We didn't usually call them "catfish". The more common local term was "hornpout".
 
  • #11
This reminds me of how Gerald Durrell (brother of the author Lawrence Durrell) got a python to his zoo:

On a field trip to South Africa, the natives said that a large python was lurking beneath a tree root some distance away from the village where they were staying.
One of the brave young men even bragged how he knew to catch it:

When they arrived at the tree root, the native simply stuck his foot and leg into the hole where the python was, and swayed his leg enticingly back and forth.
Suddenly, he felt how the python wrapped itself around his leg, and he withdrew it quickly, the python following obligingly. And that is how Gerald Durrell got his python..

I guess some guys are a bit braver than me..
 
  • #12
DAMN! That's a real man's sport right there. Almost as manly as diving into the ocean and murdering whales with a harpoon.
 
  • #13
Entropy said:
DAMN! That's a real man's sport right there. Almost as manly as diving into the ocean and murdering whales with a harpoon.
Whales??
Try a school of sharks for some real action.
 
  • #14
Try sharks for some real action.

Whales are bigger than sharks, pal. Every read Mobby Dick (I know it's not really accurate)? Try diving into the water, stabbing a whale to death and hauling its corpes onto your boat. Also, most sharks are fished for with a rod. Whales you have to harpoon.

Plus, whales are stupid animals and deserve to die, just like dolphins and manatees. I hate manatees. All that do is float around and get hit by boats. What kind of animal gets hit by a boat? It isn't like you can't hear them coming a mile away. They purposely let themselves get hit to try and break some honest guy's motor, just out of spite.

Thats why I suggest we have a manatee hunting season. They call them the sea cow, I wonder if they taste like regular cow? Anyone up for manatee burgers?
 
  • #15
Whale tastes good...don't know about manatee, though.
 
  • #16
Ooh, we have a new sport to teach Franzbear. I think it would be an excellent bonding experience for him and his Uncle Artman (I think I'll stay home and get the frying pan seasoned :rolleyes:).
 
  • #17
Great idea! Why didn't I think of that?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
9K