Petition for NASA to name TOI-1338 b in honor of musician SOPHIE

  • Context: Music 
  • Thread starter Thread starter AndreasC
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Nasa
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around a petition to NASA to name the exoplanet TOI-1338 b in honor of the musician SOPHIE, who is recognized for her influence on the LGBTQIA+ community and her artistic contributions. Participants explore the implications of naming astronomical bodies after cultural figures, the significance of such gestures, and the potential prioritization of entertainment over scientific recognition.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express support for the petition, highlighting SOPHIE's impact on her fanbase and the LGBTQIA+ community.
  • Others question the appropriateness of naming a planet after a musician, suggesting it diminishes the recognition of scientific achievements.
  • Some argue that there are already many astronomical bodies named after various cultural figures, indicating a precedent for such naming conventions.
  • A few participants suggest that the petition could serve as a symbolic gesture rather than a serious scientific proposal.
  • Concerns are raised about cultural appropriation and the perceived trivialization of science through such actions.
  • There are discussions about the nature of irony and sarcasm in the context of the petition and the responses to it.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the appropriateness of naming TOI-1338 b after SOPHIE. There are competing views regarding the significance of such a gesture and its implications for the recognition of scientific contributions versus cultural figures.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express uncertainty about the long-term significance of SOPHIE's music and its cultural impact, while others defend her contributions as meaningful within specific demographics. The discussion reflects a variety of perspectives on the intersection of science and popular culture.

AndreasC
Gold Member
Messages
555
Reaction score
317
https://www.change.org/p/nasa-nasa-name-toi-1338-in-honor-of-sophie

Copied from the petition text:

Sophie Xeon, known mononymously as SOPHIE, was a highly influential singer, songwriter, and producer who was a great inspiration to the LGBTQIA+ community. Her messages, actions, and music left an insurmountable impression on many LGBTQIA+ individuals. She always pushed a message of individuality and expressing your true self which resonated throughout everything she did.

SOPHIE tragically passed away Saturday, January 30th, 2021 around 4:00 AM EET, in Athens, Greece after an accident while attempting to see the full moon. This event has devastated her fanbase, which had looked up to her for inspiration. A fanbase that took her messages and ran with them, further spreading her influence.

When artist renditions of TOI 1338 b (a circumbinary exoplanet discovered by Wolf Cukier and fellow scientists at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center) were featured in the press following the 235th American Astronomical Society meeting in Honolulu, many fans noticed the similarities between the interpretations and the aesthetic sense of SOPHIE’s visual work, specifically the cover for her 2018 album Oil of Every Pearl’s UnInsides.

I am requesting, at the discretion of the incredible scientists who discovered the planet, that TOI 1338 b be named in honor of the great LGBT+ influence, SOPHIE. Her fans would love to pay homage by having her name be remembered in this way and for her influence to continue to flourish for years to come.
 
Science news on Phys.org
Why petition NASA? Why not petition the Commissioner of Major League baseball?
 
Vanadium 50 said:
Why petition NASA? Why not petition the Commissioner of Major League baseball?
We can petition him too!

Yeah I know the way it's framed is kinda dumb but at least that way the idea may get some exposure.
 
AndreasC said:
We can petition him too!

Yeah I know the way it's framed is kinda dumb but at least that way the idea may get some exposure.
Why name a planet after a singer? Surely there will be plenty of accolades from the world of entertainment? There is so little recognition for scientists generally, that this feels like a statement that science is worth little compared to the world of pop music.

Sorry, I would take this as a sign that the world has its priorities all wrong.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz and Hamiltonian
PeroK said:
Why name a planet after a singer? Surely there will be plenty of acolades from the world of entertainment? There is so little recognition for scientists generally, that this feels like a statement that science is worth little compared to the world of pop music.

Sorry, I would take this as a sign that the world has its priorities all wrong.
Ι wouldn't be that cynical. I guess someone can argue that exoplanets are more important than asteroids, but there are plenty of asteroids named after various random scientists, as well as pop personalities etc. There actually are exoplanets named after types of trees or characters from semi-obscure books. I guess if you don't know who SOPHIE is and don't have much connection to her music or the subculture surrounding it, I can't really convince you that it's a big deal. Well, it's not a big deal but it would be a nice thing to happen, especially considering the circumstances of her death.

Somewhat ironically, SOPHIE is actually one of the more underappreciated pop musicians. She is important for a certain demographic, but also she has produced a number of songs for more mainstream artists and she is especially well appreciated among musicians since her music is very original and a very bold departure from the usual in her genre, which is part of why she is not one of the best known artists. Like it or not (and you probably won't if you listen to it lol) it's actually novel and important. There are artists like that in every era, people whose music influences the course of the genre but is too weird or bold to become as popular as everything else. For instance the Velvet Underground comes to mind for music in the 60s. So this is not exactly a case of "I want to name this planet after Kim Kardashian" or something.

Lastly, there's no shortage of astronomical bodies in need of a nickname. So there is nothing stopping us from doing both!
 
Last edited:
PeroK said:
Why name a planet after a singer? Surely there will be plenty of acolades from the world of entertainment? There is so little recognition for scientists generally, that this feels like a statement that science is worth little compared to the world of pop music.

Sounds like a new form of cultural mis-appropriation!
Science is once again being taken advantage of!
When will it ever end?
 
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: berkeman, Vanadium 50 and Klystron
BillTre said:
Sounds like a new form of cultural mis-appropriation!
Science is once again being taken advantage of!
When will it ever end?
I'm not sure how this is science being "taken advantage of" or cultural appropriation. I don't see this hurting anything, it's simply a symbolic gesture. And cultural appropriation isn't applicable here.
 
  • Wow
Likes   Reactions: BillTre
AndreasC said:
I'm not sure how this is science being "taken advantage of" or cultural appropriation. I don't see this hurting anything, it's simply a symbolic gesture. And cultural appropriation isn't applicable here.
Its a joke. Don't take it too seriously. :wink:
 
BillTre said:
Its a joke. Don't take it too seriously. :wink:
Ah alright, I'm sorry, irony doesn't always translate well in the internet!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Klystron and BillTre
  • #10
AndreasC said:
Ah alright, I'm sorry, irony doesn't always translate well in the internet!
True. I gave up sarcasm after several disastrous attempts at 'reverse sarcasm', popular among teens.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: AndreasC
  • #11
I forgot to use an emoji :bow:
 
  • #12
BillTre said:
Its a joke. Don't take it too seriously. :wink:
AndreasC said:
Ah alright, I'm sorry, irony doesn't always translate well in the internet!
Yeah, she is already getting a Darwin award. We should not pile on too many extra honors, IMO... :wink:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz
  • #13
AndreasC said:
Ι wouldn't be that cynical.
I wasn't being cynical. If I was being cynical, I would say something like.

Sophie's supporters realize that her music alone won't stand the test of time - that it's stylised and vacuous and will soon be forgotten. It's necessary, therefore, to attach her name to something more permanent in a vain attempt to immortalise someone whom they wish to believe is special, but who is ultimately just another ordinary human being, with no special talents to distinguish her from the other 7.7 billion souls on this planet.

And her contribution to science? That she has an album cover that looks a bit like a photo of a recently discovered exoplanet.

Now that would be cynical.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz
  • #14
PeroK said:
I wasn't being cynical. If I was being cynical, I would say something like.

Sophie's supporters realize that her music alone won't stand the test of time - that it's stylised and vacuous and will soon be forgotten. It's necessary, therefore, to attach her name to something more permanent in a vain attempt to immortalise someone whom they wish to believe is special, but who is ultimately just another ordinary human being, with no special talents to distinguish her from the other 7.7 billion souls on this planet.

And her contribution to science? That she has an album cover that looks a bit like a photo of a recently discovered exoplanet.

Now that would be cynical.
It would also be wrong.
 
  • #15
AndreasC said:
It would also be wrong.
Perhaps so. But, look at it this way. If I discovered a new planet, I might want to name it after my favourite musician; not yours.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz
  • #16
PeroK said:
Perhaps so. But, look at it this way. If I discovered a new planet, I might want to name it after my favourite musician; not yours.
Then you could do a petition.
 
  • #17
AndreasC said:
Then you could do a petition.
You miss the point. If you discover a planet or a comet or something, you would have a case to name it yourself. You wouldn't have to petition someone else to name their discovery according to your wishes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz
  • #18
PeroK said:
You miss the point. If you discover a planet or a comet or something, you would have a case to name it yourself. You wouldn't have to petition someone else to name their discovery according to your wishes.
I mean, so far no one named that discovery, same with most other exoplanets and asteroids, so...
 
  • #19
AndreasC said:
I guess someone can argue that exoplanets are more important than asteroids, but there are plenty of asteroids named after various random scientists, as well as pop personalities etc.

There are also a great many more of them.

By deciding that an asteroid isn't good enough, and the other exoplanets aren't good enough and it has to be this one (because an artist's conception of the planet is kind of pastel-y like one of her album covers), the odds of success are lowered. By addressing the petition to the wrong people (NASA), the odds are lowered further.
 
  • #20
Vanadium 50 said:
There are also a great many more of them
They're still ever growing though.

Vanadium 50 said:
By deciding that an asteroid isn't good enough
I don't think this mentions an exoplanet because an asteroid is not good enough. I don't think people would mind if it was an asteroid instead of an exoplanet.

It could be any other exoplanet, one is not much better than the other, but eh, this has to be about something so why not this one. It's not terribly important. You're digging too much into it.
 
  • #21
AndreasC said:
You're digging too much into it.

I'm reading the request as written. You might be happy with the alternatives. That doesn't mean everybody is. I can only go by what was written. And I stand by my statement that the petition authors made some mistakes.
 
  • #22
Vanadium 50 said:
I'm reading the request as written. You might be happy with the alternatives. That doesn't mean everybody is. I can only go by what was written. And I stand by my statement that the petition authors made some mistakes.
Sure, I agree they made some mistakes, but petitions aren't terribly important. They just give an idea some extra exposure, and gauge interest. So if people are interested, they can sign it, and maybe it will take some more exposure that way! If not, that's alright, it's not that important.