Forum software upgrade planned for Monday or Tuesday
- Thread starter Greg Bernhardt
- Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
73 replies · 9K views
Physics news on Phys.org
FZ+
- 1,599
- 3
Go greg! Go greg!
Much better, thanks!
Much better, thanks!
Gara
- 152
- 0
if there isnt, how about a user side custom theme colour settings?
i also had to readd my avatar. and omg wheres my sig message gone??
and i like the blue bar. it helps to know when one post ends and another starts.
i also had to readd my avatar. and omg wheres my sig message gone??
and i like the blue bar. it helps to know when one post ends and another starts.
Last edited:
Evo
Staff Emeritus
- 24,114
- 3,277
The option to be invisible is gone.
We can't customize avatars anymore either? I didn't see an option for it.
We can't customize avatars anymore either? I didn't see an option for it.
- 19,980
- 11,080
Evo said:The option to be invisible is gone.
We can't customize avatars anymore either? I didn't see an option for it.
As you already have seen I am setting up to offer paid memberships, which will include certain perks
Dagenais
- 293
- 4
As you already have seen I am setting up to offer paid memberships, which will include certain perks
The perks are features you ripped away from under the "free" users' noses?
- 19,980
- 11,080
Dagenais said:The perks are features you ripped away from under the "free" users' noses?![]()
Some yes, some no. Ripped away eh? Nice drama touch
Evo
Staff Emeritus
- 24,114
- 3,277
I had a sneaking suspiscion that was what you had in mind.Greg Bernhardt said:As you already have seen I am setting up to offer paid memberships, which will include certain perks![]()
Very clever!
Gara
- 152
- 0
wtf? avatars and sigs will have to be paid for? that's just wrong.
______________________________________
there's something here from somewhere else.
It's all over and I'm standing pretty,
In this dust that was a city.
______________________________________
there's something here from somewhere else.
It's all over and I'm standing pretty,
In this dust that was a city.
- 19,980
- 11,080
Gara said:wtf? avatars and sigs will have to be paid for? that's just wrong.
I'm sorry you feel this way. If you enjoy and appreciate PF you'll sign up for the paid memberships. Give back to your community, the fees will be about as much as a bag of chips per month.
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 2,284
- 3
It may seem dictatorial or unjust, but you have to consider the other side of the equation. PF does not exist in a vacuum; it needs funding to continue to exist, and the money pulled in from the banner ads does not cover it. The prices being discussed are not prohibitive in any sense. If you badly want an avatar and signature, you can pay a small, essentially negligible fee and in the process contribute to the continued existence of PF; if not, you can still disucss ideas, share information and the like without paying.
In an ideal world perhaps it would not be like this, but the fact of the matter is that there are financial requirements that need to be met in some way or another. The idea is to ensure that these requirements are met while not sacrificing the spirit of free discourse. For this reason I think it is entirely reasonable that peripheral features such as avatars and signatures, which are attractive and nice but which nonetheless are not essential to the basic workings of the site, require a small fee. It makes one more likely to offer badly needed financial support to PF while at the same time not making the cost of refusing to pay prohibitive.
In an ideal world perhaps it would not be like this, but the fact of the matter is that there are financial requirements that need to be met in some way or another. The idea is to ensure that these requirements are met while not sacrificing the spirit of free discourse. For this reason I think it is entirely reasonable that peripheral features such as avatars and signatures, which are attractive and nice but which nonetheless are not essential to the basic workings of the site, require a small fee. It makes one more likely to offer badly needed financial support to PF while at the same time not making the cost of refusing to pay prohibitive.
jimmy p
Gold Member
- 419
- 73
Yeah, uh how is this paying thing going to work cos i know a lot of you are in USA but what about your foreign visitors?. I feel so regular. A "registered user" with no Va Va Voom...dont take that away from me Greg! Oh yeah, colour scheme is brightish, quite pleasing to the eye, it will take some getting used to however. Congrats
edit...oh wait, I am still Chopnik. WOOT!
VA VA VOOM!
edit...oh wait, I am still Chopnik. WOOT!
VA VA VOOM!
Tsu
Gold Member
- 462
- 62
You'll ALWAYS be Chopnik!jimmy p said:edit...oh wait, I am still Chopnik. WOOT!
VA VA VOOM!
I notice there are no signatures anymore, either. Will these be among the 'paid member only' items?
Tsu
Gold Member
- 462
- 62
Why does the Quick Reply give you the option to 'quote message in reply' but NOT LET YOU CLICK IT? And whose message would be quoted if we WERE allowed to click it? I realize it's kind of a moot point, but I was just curious.
- 19,980
- 11,080
Tsunami said:Why does the Quick Reply give you the option to 'quote message in reply' but NOT LET YOU CLICK IT? And whose message would be quoted if we WERE allowed to click it? I realize it's kind of a moot point, but I was just curious.
Yes. And see that icon next to the quote button for each thread? Click that and then proceed to the quick reply, the checkbox will be enabled.
Gara
- 152
- 0
i know a place like this has to make money in some way.
it just makes Gara sad :(
______________________________________
there's something here from somewhere else.
It's all over and I'm standing pretty,
In this dust that was a city.
it just makes Gara sad :(
______________________________________
there's something here from somewhere else.
It's all over and I'm standing pretty,
In this dust that was a city.
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 10,270
- 45
The payment structure that Greg is proposing here is one that I've seen work successfully on a number of other forums. It's the fairest way to deal with it, IMO. Not having a custom avatar does not make the site any less useful to you -- you're really paying the fee not to use pf, but to support it. The custom avatar and so on is just a perk.
- Warren
- Warren
Dagenais
- 293
- 4
I'm sorry you feel this way. If you enjoy and appreciate PF you'll sign up for the paid memberships. Give back to your community, the fees will be about as much as a bag of chips per month.
But I don't have the money!
I must have my Montreal Canadiens logo!
Ripped away eh? Nice drama touch
Thanks, I'm working on my writing
Last edited:
Evo
Staff Emeritus
- 24,114
- 3,277
So, when do we get to sign up & pay and get all the spiffy perks?
Have you considered accepting Western Union money transfers? Just about anyone in the world can pay cash & have it sent to you. It's much more wide spread than Paypal. Paypal is also limited to credit cards and bank transfers.
Have you considered accepting Western Union money transfers? Just about anyone in the world can pay cash & have it sent to you. It's much more wide spread than Paypal. Paypal is also limited to credit cards and bank transfers.
Gara
- 152
- 0
okay.
1) through donations, PF is secure, and not in any great need for money.
2) a bag of crisps per month is about 30p.
this is just stupid. the action of paying such a tiny amount outweighs the amount you are paying!
1) through donations, PF is secure, and not in any great need for money.
2) a bag of crisps per month is about 30p.
this is just stupid. the action of paying such a tiny amount outweighs the amount you are paying!
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 4,229
- 61
Feel free to give more.. in the past there have been members who have donated to this forum, which keeps it up and running for everyone to enjoy. It should be the bussiness of everyone who enjoys the forums to chip in a few cents. If one doesn't have the means or the feeling to donate, you'd still be able to enjoy and participate in all the discussions.. sounds fair.Gara said:okay.
1) through donations, PF is secure, and not in any great need for money.
2) a bag of crisps per month is about 30p.
this is just stupid. the action of paying such a tiny amount outweighs the amount you are paying!
- 19,980
- 11,080
Gara said:okay.
1) through donations, PF is secure, and not in any great need for money.
2) a bag of crisps per month is about 30p.
this is just stupid. the action of paying such a tiny amount outweighs the amount you are paying!
Ok Gara just for you the membership will be $100
This new layout is already starting to grow on me so who made the new PF banner and what does the equation stand for? It looks really good!
I made the banner

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 10,270
- 45
I like the banner too -- well, the left half of it. I would have rather seen the equation on the right simply made gray or white, to make it visible against the background, rather than using that awful white glow effect.
My 0.02.
- Warren
My 0.02.
- Warren
jimmy p
Gold Member
- 419
- 73
lol looks like Greg is strategically ignoring mine and Evo's question about european payment, maybe i won't have to pay...WOOT
CHOPNIK LIVES ON!
CHOPNIK LIVES ON!
Dagenais
- 293
- 4
Since I am French Canadian, I deserve special treatment.
I get all the paid features, without having to pay.
How about it?
I get all the paid features, without having to pay.
How about it?
Similar threads
Announcement Moderate forum software upgrade 4/10
- Greg Bernhardt
- · Replies 91 ·
- Feedback and Announcements
- Replies
- 91