PH Indicator and Endpoint Observations

  • Topic: Chemistry 
  • Thread starter i_love_science
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Ph
3 replies · 2K views · last reply
i_love_science
Messages
80
Reaction score
2
Homework Statement
see below
Relevant Equations
titration curve
A weak base is titrated with a strong acid.
Titration curve of pH versus volume of 0.125 M HCl added to 25.0 mL of a weak base, with points A through F marked along the curve; pH falls from about 11 to about 1 with a steep drop near 23 mL.

Multiple-choice question text: If the student uses a pH indicator that changes color from pH 6 to 8, which statement best characterizes the expected observations? Options (A) through (D) describe color change speed, endpoint volume, and calculated base molarity.


I think that both B and C are correct. The endpoint volume will be lower than the actual equivalence point volume. When the student mistakenly assumes the endpoint volume is the equivalence point volume, the number of moles of strong acid is seen as equal to the number of moles of weak base. The calculated number of moles of strong acid would be lower (because of the lower volume), and the molarity of the weak base would also be lower.

The answer says only B is correct. Could anyone explain why, and where I went wrong? Thanks.
 
I see nothing wrong in your explanation, I would choose B and C as well.

Funny thing is, this titration is still doable, you just have to do it in the opposite direction and stop at the first color change. That's how titrations against phenolphthaleine are done :smile:
 
Borek said:
Funny thing is, this titration is still doable, you just have to do it in the opposite direction and stop at the first color change. That's how titrations against phenolphthaleine are done :smile:
Thanks, though I don't really understand the above part. If you do it in the opposite direction, the color change is still not at the equivalence point...
 
i_love_science said:
Thanks, though I don't really understand the above part. If you do it in the opposite direction, the color change is still not at the equivalence point...
Which is why you stop at the first sight of color change. Color change is not instantaneous, it takes place gradually over at least 2 pH units. In the case of phenolphthalein it means the color change (when titrating strong acid with a strong base) starts quite closely to the equivalence.

Compare http://www.titrations.info/acid-base-titration-indicators