Should Pizza Sauce Count as a Vegetable in School Lunches?

  • Thread starter Thread starter G01
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the controversial classification of pizza sauce as a vegetable in school lunches, particularly focusing on the legislative support for this classification due to lobbying from tomato and sodium interests. The bill allows tomato paste, which is primarily concentrated tomato solids, to be counted as a vegetable despite nutritional debates surrounding its inclusion. Critics argue that this classification undermines nutritional standards, while proponents highlight the potential benefits of making school lunches more accessible.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of US nutritional guidelines and regulations
  • Familiarity with the role of lobbying in food policy
  • Knowledge of the composition and standards of tomato paste as per 21 CFR 155.191
  • Awareness of the economic factors affecting school lunch programs
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the impact of lobbying on food policy decisions
  • Examine the nutritional standards for school lunches set by the USDA
  • Investigate the economic implications of healthier food options in schools
  • Learn about the composition and health implications of tomato-based products
USEFUL FOR

Policy makers, nutritionists, educators, and parents interested in understanding the implications of food classifications in school nutrition programs.

G01
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
2,704
Reaction score
19
This points out how our government usually just ignores the interest of the little guy. Luckily, in this uplifting story, we see that the small, usually ignored tomato and sodium lobbies are finally having their interests looked after. Too long have they be discriminated against in the recommendations of nutritionists. Sometimes, the system does work...


http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/health/tomato-sauce-pizza-a-vegetable-congress-gop-healthier-school-lunches-expensive-article-1.978339


:rolleyes:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
G01 said:
This points out how our government usually just ignores the interest of the little guy. Luckily, in this uplifting story, we see that the small, usually ignored tomato and sodium lobbies are finally having their interests looked after. Too long have they be discriminated against in the recommendations of nutritionists. Sometimes, the system does work...


http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/health/tomato-sauce-pizza-a-vegetable-congress-gop-healthier-school-lunches-expensive-article-1.978339


:rolleyes:

Yeah, John Stewart had a piece on this last night. Disgusting.
 
Well, just playing Devil's Advocate, is there anything about pizza sauce that should exclude it from being counted (nutritionally speaking) as a vegetable? Not that "sauce" is a vegetable, but if it contains one serving of vegetables then it seems fair to me.

Also, the article only says "tomato paste" is counted. From the article provided:
The bill also would allow tomato paste on pizzas to be counted as a vegetable, as it is now.

However, in the US, tomato paste does not usually contain salt (granted there is a provision allowing for it):
In the USA, tomato paste is concentrated tomato solids (no seeds or skin) and usually no added sugars or seasonings, with a standard of identity (see 21 CFR 155.191).
(2) Optional ingredients. One or any
combination of two or more of the following safe and suitable ingredients
may be used in the foods:
(i) Salt (sodium chloride formed during acid neutralization shall be considered added salt).
(ii) Lemon juice, concentrated lemon
juice, or organic acids.
(iii) Sodium bicarbonate.
(iv) Water, as provided for in paragraph (a)(1) of this section.
(v) Spices.
(vi) Flavoring.
(Source: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/cfr_2010/aprqtr/pdf/21cfr155.191.pdf)

Further, as to the point that healthier foods are more expensive and therefore cost prohibitive, I tend to disagree, but if you accept that as a fact, then isn't that sufficient reason not to include them in school lunches? As it is a "school lunch" is ridiculously subsidized. I ate my share of them all the way from elementary school to high school. We always had access to a calendar that told us what would be available to eat each day and were never "surprised" by french fries or pizzas. On rare occasions I would ask my mom for a sandwich in lieu of "mystery meat" day... or my mom might step in and provide snacks or an apple to supplement my meal.

I think it's really too much to ask our school cafeterias to take over the role of nutritional counsel for the children AND parents of America.
 
Last edited: