Sociology of Physics: comment and indices

marcus · Aug 29, 2014

Code:

period          1999-2001   2002-2004   2005-2007   2008-2010  2011-2013    2014
HEP theory overall   18         24          23          13         13         9
string                9          8           6           2          2         1

Source: http://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~poppitz/Jobs94-08
http://particle.physics.ucdavis.edu/rumor/doku.php
For additional detail see post #403

Another useful link (QG-related postdoc and junior faculty appointments)
https://sites.google.com/site/grqcrumourmill/

2014 Postdoc Positions:
Erlangen - Nuremberg U. (loop quantum gravity) - position filled
Fudan U. (gravity/cosmology/astrophysics) - Offered to: Pietro Donà (SISSA; accepted)
Hamburg U. (discrete QG, diff-inv. path integral measures) - Offered to: Sebastian Steinhaus (Perimeter Inst.; accepted)
Nijmegen U. (non-perturb. quantum gravity) - Offered to: Jeff Hnybida (Perimeter Inst.; accepted)
Nottingham U. (modified gravity, ...) - ?
Nottingham U. Offered to: Lisa Glaser (Bohr Inst.; accepted)
Oxford U. Offered to: David Sloan (Cambridge U., DAMTP; accepted)
Penn State U. (quantum gravity, cosmology) - Offered to: Brajesh Gupt (Louisiana State U.; accepted)
Perimeter Inst. Theor. Phys. (quantum gravity, ...) - Offered to: Aldo Riello (Marseille, CPT; accepted)
Perimeter Inst. Theor. Phys. (quantum gravity, ...) - Offered to: Yasha Neiman (Penn State U.; accepted)
Potsdam, Max Planck Inst. (string theory and other...) - Offered to: Daniele Dorigoni (DAMTP, Cambridge),
Potsdam, Max Planck Inst. (quantum gravity) - Offered to: Edward Wilson-Ewing (Louisiana State U.; accepted)

External Fellowships:
Mingyi Zhang (Marseille, CPT) -> Fudan U. (1 year) -> Potsdam, Max Planck Inst. (Humboldt Fellowship)
Steffen Gielen (Perimeter Inst.) -> Imperial College, London (Marie Curie Fellowship)
Francesca Vidotto (Nijmegen U.) -> Nijmegen U. (Veni Fellowship)

Tenure Track/Faculty Positions:
Muxin Han (Marseille, CPT) -> Florida Atlantic U.
Dario Benedetti (Potsdam, Max Planck Inst.) -> CNRS, France (faculty)
Hal Haggard (Marseille, CPT) -> Bard College (faculty)
Thomas P. Sotiriou and Silke Weinfurtner (SISSA) -> Nottingham U. (faculty)

marcus · Sep 11, 2014

Code:

period          1999-2001   2002-2004   2005-2007   2008-2010  2011-2013    2014
HEP theory overall   18         24          23          13         13         9
string                9          8           6           2          2         1

Source: http://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~poppitz/Jobs94-08
http://particle.physics.ucdavis.edu/rumor/doku.php
For additional detail see post #403

marcus · Sep 30, 2014

change over time in quantum cosmology research:
"quantum cosmology" 1995-1999, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" and d 1995->1999 NOT d 1900->1994&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (395 found as of 30 Sep 2014)

"quantum cosmology" and not "loop" 1995-1999, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" and not "loop" and d 1995->1999 NOT d 1900->1994&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (368 as of 30 Sep 2014)

"quantum cosmology" since 2009, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p= "quantum cosmology" and NOT d 1900->2008&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (727 found as of 30 Sep 2014)

"quantum cosmology" and not "loop" since 2009, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" and not "loop" and NOT d 1900->2008&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (358 as of 30 Sep 2014)

So before year 2000 very little of QC was Loop, most used other types of approaches to treating early universe quantum theoretically. Then after 2000 the proportion changed. Since 2009 about half of QC research is Loop (only about half is non-Loop)

Does it make any difference if we add "ekpyrotic" to the search?
To repeat, here it is without:
"quantum cosmology" since 2009, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p= "quantum cosmology" and NOT d 1900->2008&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (727 found as of 30 Sep 2014)
Here it is with ekpyrotic added:
"quantum cosmology" or "ekpyrotic" Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" or "ekpyrotic" and NOT d 1900->2008&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (787 as of 30 Sep 2014)
Adjoining "ekpyrotic" does not increase the total by all that much.

It's interesting to look at the half of the QC papers that are NOT LQC-related to see the variety of quantum cosmology alternatives (e.g. matter-bounce, modified gravity, teleparallel gravity, Steinhardt-cyclic…)

marcus · Oct 2, 2014

Code:

period          1999-2001   2002-2004   2005-2007   2008-2010  2011-2013    2014
HEP theory overall   18         24          23          13         13         9
string                9          8           6           2          2         1

Source: http://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~poppitz/Jobs94-08
http://particle.physics.ucdavis.edu/rumor/doku.php
For additional detail see post #403, and also:
https://sites.google.com/site/grqcrumourmill/

marcus · Oct 6, 2014

As of 6 Oct (279/365) research output for 2014.
Loop-related: 144 annualized from 110 found
String-related: 591 annualized from 452 found

As of 21 Oct (294/365)
Loop-related: 146 annualized from 118 found
String-related: 597 annualized from 481 found

As of 30 Oct (303/365)
Loop-related: 146 annualized from 121 found
627 annualized from539 found
String-related: 637 annualized from 529 found

As of 3 Nov (307/365)
Loop-related: 147 annualized from 124 found
String-related: 633 annualized from 532 found

As of 10 Nov (314/365)
Loop-related: 148 annualized from 127 found
String-related: 627 annualized from 539 found

As of 20 Nov (324/365)
Loop-related: 148 annualized from 131 found
String-related: 624 annualized from 554 found

http://www.calendardate.com/todays.htm

marcus · Oct 15, 2014

At noon on 15 Oct the sales ranks of the pop-string top five (elegant, fabric, grand, hidden, parallel) averaged
6283+11369+14471+16040+16585)/5 = 12950

Spot check at 5pm on 20 Oct: the stringy top five (elegant, grand, hidden, fabric, parallel) ranked an average of
(7303+13224+13293+16586+30127)/5 = 16107

Spot check around noon on 1 Nov: elegant, fabric, grand, e-elegant, parallel averaged
(7733+9969+10403+12451+15090)/5 = 11129

For comparison over time:

Code:

Midmonth averages of pop-string top five Amazon sales ranks,
recorded at Pacific noon on and around the 15th of each month
July 2009           6485
November 2009         NA
March 2010          7521
July  2010          8461
November 2010       2220
March 2011           349
July  2011          1257
November 2011       1243
March 2012          3235
July  2012          2359
November 2012       7792
March 2013          7396
July  2013          9168
November 2013      10558
March 2014          7065
July  2014          9582
(15 Oct 2014)      12950
(20 Oct 2014)      16107 
(01 Nov 2014)      11129

marcus · Oct 25, 2014

A sign of the times, the #1 and #2 physics bestsellers at Amazon Italia are #46 and #149 respectively among all books being sold.

Bestseller di Amazon

I nostri prodotti più popolari, in base alle vendite. Aggiornato ogni ora.
Bestseller in Fisica

1.
41LuOPIkqcL._SL160_SL150_.jpg

Sette brevi lezioni di fisica
di Carlo Rovelli
Copertina flessibile
EUR 8,50

2.
51gVhuLkLTL._SL160_SL150_.jpg

La realtà non è come ci appare. La st...
di Carlo Rovelli
4.8 su 5 stelle (36)
Copertina flessibile
EUR 18,70

marcus · Oct 27, 2014

Bestseller in Fisica

1.
41LuOPIkqcL._SL160_SL150_.jpg

Sette brevi lezioni di fisica
di Carlo Rovelli
Copertina flessibile
EUR 8,50
2.
51gVhuLkLTL._SL160_SL150_.jpg

La realtà non è come ci appare. La st...
di Carlo Rovelli
4.8 su 5 stelle (36)
Copertina flessibile
EUR 18,70
3.
41oqELd1FCL._SL160_SL150_.jpg

Sette brevi lezioni di fisica (Piccol...
di Carlo Rovelli
Formato Kindle
EUR 4,99

(As of 27 October: #33, #97 in Books, and #255 in Kindle)
(As of 1 November: #22, #31, in Books, and #108 in Kindle)
On the Physics bestseller list there is little change, they remain fairly steady at #1, #2, #3 in the indicated order.

marcus · Nov 10, 2014

Shifting over to recording February, June, October mid month sale rank averages, instead of March, July, November.
At noon on 15 Oct the sales ranks of the pop-string top five (elegant, fabric, grand, hidden, parallel) averaged
(6283+11369+14471+16040+16585)/5 = 12950

Code:

Midmonth averages of pop-string top five Amazon sales ranks,
recorded at Pacific noon on and around the 15th of each month
July 2009           6485
November 2009         NA
March 2010          7521
July  2010          8461
November 2010       2220
March 2011           349
July  2011          1257
November 2011       1243
March 2012          3235
July  2012          2359
November 2012       7792
March 2013          7396
July  2013          9168
November 2013      10558
March 2014          7065
July  2014          9582
October 2014       12950

marcus · Nov 15, 2014

Last year in Usa and Canada there were only 9 first-time faculty hires in HEP-TH (high energy theory) one of which was in string (others in phenom. , cosmo., lattice gauge, etc.
This year there seem to be many more announced openings in hep-th, namely 23. I will quote from the usual source and try to estimate what fraction of these mention string. N means not mentioned, Y means string mentioned (along with half a dozen or more other specializations).
======quote from http://particle.physics.ucdavis.edu/rumor/doku.php ======
2015 Faculty Jobs:

Austin (deadline Oct. 1)N
Short List:
Offered To:

http://www.baylor.edu/hr/index.php?id=81294 (deadline Nov. 1)N
Short List:
Offered To:

Boston (deadline Nov. 20)N*
Short List:
Offered To:

Brown (deadline Dec. 1)N
Short List:
Offered To:

http://www.carleton.ca/facultyrecruitment/2014/department-of-physics-theoretical-particle-physics-assistant-professor/ (deadline Nov. 1)N
Short List:
Offered To:

Chicago (deadline Nov. 15)Y
Short List:
Offered To:

Davis (four positions, open until filled)N
Short List:
Offered To:

Johns Hopkins (deadline Dec. 1)Y
Short List:
Offered To:

Kansas (deadline Oct. 31)N
Short List:
Offered To:

Kentucky (deadline Dec. 1)Y
Short List:
Offered To:

Michigan (deadline Nov. 1)N
Short List:
Offered To:

MIT (deadline Nov. 21)Y
Short List:
Offered To:

Northeastern (deadline Jan. 15)N
Short List:
Offered To:

http://www.physicsandastronomy.pitt.edu/about/department_openings (deadline Nov. 30)N (phenom.)
Short List:
Offered To:

Princeton (deadline Nov. 17)N*
Short List:
Offered To:

http://www.queensu.ca/physics/canada-research-chair-theoretical-particle-astrophysics (deadline Feb. 15)N (astro)
Short List:
Offered To:

San Francisco (deadline Dec. 1)Y
Short List:
Offered To:

SLAC (deadline Dec. 1)Y
Short List:
Offered To:

Stanford (deadline Dec. 1) N (phenom, connect w exper.)
Short List:
Offered To:

Swarthmore N
Short List:
Bartlomiej Czech
...
Offered To:

UCLA (deadline Dec. 31) N (phenom, astroparticle, etc)
Short List:
Offered To:

http://umass.interviewexchange.com/jobofferdetails.jsp;jsessionid=6C7C1A4A0FFF9D9D253A25368BDB4FFF?JOBID=53338 (deadline Dec. 1) N
Short List:
Offered To:

Wisconsin-Madison (deadline Dec. 1) N (astroparticle, cosmo)
Short List:
Offered To:

marcus · Dec 3, 2014

Code:

period          1999-2001   2002-2004   2005-2007   2008-2010  2011-2013    2014
HEP theory overall   18         24          23          13         13         9
string                9          8           6           2          2         1

Source: http://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~poppitz/Jobs94-08
http://particle.physics.ucdavis.edu/rumor/doku.php
For additional detail see post #403, and also:
https://sites.google.com/site/grqcrumourmill/

I'll bring forward some quantum cosmology links:

"quantum cosmology" since 2009, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p= "quantum cosmology" and NOT d 1900->2008&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (753 found as of 6 Dec 2014)

"quantum cosmology" and not "loop" since 2009, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" and not "loop" and NOT d 1900->2008&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (372 as of 6 Dec 2014)

From 2009 onwards quantum cosmology research has been about half loop-related and half non-loop.
Before year 2000 it was almost all non-loop. So there has been a shift in research activity and interest.

"quantum cosmology" 1995-1999, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" and d 1995->1999 NOT d 1900->1994&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (396 found as of 6 Dec 2014)

"quantum cosmology" and not "loop" 1995-1999, Inspire search:
http://inspirehep.net/search?ln=en&ln=en&p="quantum cosmology" and not "loop" and d 1995->1999 NOT d 1900->1994&of=hb&action_search=Search&sf=&so=d&rm=citation&rg=25&sc=0 (369 as of 6 Dec 2014)

marcus · Dec 15, 2014

Research outputs for 2014, as of 18 December (352/365)
147 annualized from 142 found
637 annualized from 613 found

marcus · Dec 30, 2014

Code:

Midmonth averages of pop-string top five Amazon sales ranks,
recorded at Pacific noon on and around the 15th of each month
July 2009           6485
November 2009         NA
March 2010          7521
July  2010          8461
November 2010       2220
March 2011           349
July  2011          1257
November 2011       1243
March 2012          3235
July  2012          2359
November 2012       7792
March 2013          7396
July  2013          9168
November 2013      10558
March 2014          7065
July  2014          9582
October 2014       12950
(3 January 2015    11731)
(5 February 2015   11370)

5 Feb: elegant, grand, fabric, parallel, hidden (4889+7254+10435+15127+19148)/5 = 11370

marcus · Feb 5, 2015

Now that the Inspire topcite results for 2014 are posted, I want to continue this index along the lines of post #469.

marcus said:
Annual topcite lists gauge the currently perceived significance of recent work by how often it was cited by other researchers during the given year. Papers are ranked by the number of citations in other research they received that year.
Number of recent string papers making Inspire's top forty annual citations list
(some years omitted for brevity)
Code:
year           2001   2003   2005   2007   2009   2011   2012   2013
recent toppers   11     6      3      1      1      0      0      0
Here a paper is counted as recent if it appeared any time in the preceding five years.
Links to sources:
2001 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2001/annual.html (eleven)
2003 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2003/annual.html (six)
2005 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2005/annual.html (three)
2007 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2007/annual.html (one)
2009 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2009/annual.html (one)
2011 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2011/annual.html (zero)
2012 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2012/annual.html (zero)
2013 http://inspirehep.net/info/hep/stats/topcites/2013/annual.html (zero)

Only 5 string papers, none of them recent, made the 2013 top forty list. As it happened all five papers were from the period 1997-1999. This is the first time I can remember when no string papers from year 2000 or later made the top forty.

Annual topcite lists gauge the currently perceived significance of recent work by how often it was cited by other researchers during the given year. Papers are ranked by the number of citations in other research they received that year.
Number of recent string papers making Inspire's top forty annual citations list
(some years omitted for brevity)

Code:

year           2001   2003   2005   2007   2009   2011   2012   2013   2014
recent toppers   11     6      3      1      1      0      0      0      0

Sociology of Physics: comment and indices

Similar threads

Predictions for the Nobel Prize in Physics 2025 (results: John Clarke, Michel H. Devoret and John M. Martinis)

Why do we spend so little time learning grammar in college?

In the early days of electricity, they didn't have wall plugs

How do people explore new ideas in physics?

A three month long summer vacation from public school seems stupid

Insights Thinking Outside The Box Versus Knowing What’s In The Box

Insights Why Entangled Photon-Polarization Qubits Violate Bell’s Inequality

Insights Quantum Entanglement is a Kinematic Fact, not a Dynamical Effect

Insights What Exactly is Dirac’s Delta Function? - Insight

Insights Relativator (Circular Slide-Rule): Simulated with Desmos - Insight

Insights Fixing Things Which Can Go Wrong With Complex Numbers