Solving for L in Buffon's coin problem algebra

  • Thread starter musicgold
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Algebra
6 replies · 2K views · last reply
musicgold
Messages
303
Reaction score
19
Homework Statement
This is not a homework problem. I am stuck
Relevant Equations
The attached picture shows the figure and the equation I am trying to solve.
I seem to have stuck with this simple algebra problem.$$ \frac {(L - 2.r)^2 } { L^2} = 1/2 $$
$$ 2( L^2 + 4r^2 - 4rL) = L^2 $$
$$ L^2 + 8 r^2 - 8r L = 0 $$
$$ (L - 2 \sqrt 2 r )^2 = 8rL - 4\sqrt 2. rL $$
$$ (L - 2 \sqrt 2 r )^2 = 4rL. (2 -\sqrt 2) $$

I don't know how to proceed from here to get
$$ L = ( 4 + 2\sqrt 2 ) . r $$
 
Attachments
  • Printed book page with a hand-drawn diagram: a large square of side L containing a smaller square of side L minus 2r, with a circle of radius r touching the inner square's edge, and equations below for the fair-game condition.
    IMG_20201006_0546119[1].jpg
    59.9 KB · Views: 230
Last edited:
musicgold said:
$$ L^2 + 8 r^2 - 8r L = 0 $$
Isn't that a quadratic equation in ##L##?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: musicgold
PeroK said:
Isn't that a quadratic equation in ##L##?
Ah! I missed the forest for the trees. Thanks.

BTW, how should one interpret the second root of the eqaution?
$$ L = (4 - 2\sqrt 2 ). r$$
 
musicgold said:
Ah! I missed the forest for the trees. Thanks.

BTW, how should one interpret the second root of the eqaution?
$$ L = (4 - 2\sqrt 2 ). r$$
Well, ##L## must be greater than ##2r##.

There was an easier way to do this. You have:
$$(L-2r)^2 = \frac 1 2 L^2 \ \Rightarrow \ L - 2r = \frac L {\sqrt 2}$$
 
PeroK said:
$$ \ L - 2r = \frac L {\sqrt 2}$$

Not sure how to derive a conclusion from this statement.
It is saying as long as L is greater than 2r, ## \frac {L}{ \sqrt2} ## is a positive number, right?
 
I think it's just the same thing basically. You know that L > 0 and L > 2r, so that's the only version of the square roots that line up (or you can take the negative of both sides).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: musicgold
musicgold said:
Not sure how to derive a conclusion from this statement.
It is saying as long as L is greater than 2r, ## \frac {L}{ \sqrt2} ## is a positive number, right?
1) We start with a physical problem where some things are positive numbers. In this case ##L## and ##L - 2r##.

2) We set up a quadratic equation involving these quantities.

3) We take the solution that meets the physical constraint of positivity.

Sometimes the additional solutions mean something, but not in this case. There is no sense in a negative ##L##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: musicgold