Thomas precession derivation in Goldstein equation 7.19

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Coelum
Messages
97
Reaction score
32
TL;DR
While computing the transformation matrix associated to Thomas precession - as described by Goldstein (7.3) - I cannot reproduce a step in the derivation.
Dear PFer's,
I am reproducing the steps to derive the expression for the Thomas precession, as described in Goldstein/Poole/Safko "Classical Mechanics". Hereafter an excerpt from the book describing the step I am currently working on.
Book page showing equation 7.18: a 4x4 matrix L'' = L'L with entries involving gamma, beta and gamma prime, followed by text and equation 7.19 approximating beta'' and gamma'' with first-order values.

I have been able to compute the matrix L'' (eqn. 7.18). However, computing its approximation as described above (eqn 7.19 and γ' = 1), I get a different result:

4x4 matrix with entries gamma'' in the top-left, -beta''_x gamma'' and -beta''_y gamma'' in the first row, -beta''_x gamma'' and gamma'' in the second, -beta''_y gamma''^2, beta''_x beta''_y gamma''^2 and 1 in the third row, and 0, 0, 0, 1 in the last row.
.
As you can see, I get γ^2 rather than γ in the third row. I cannot find my mistake and I cannot see how γ can approximate γ^2. Any hint?
Thanks a lot in advance,

Francesco
 
Just an idea: to first order in β, γ^2 ≈ γ since γ is quadratic in β. Sort of dirty trick, but formally correct?