BaO
- 8
- 0
for example: Zn has more tendency to oxidize than Ag, orZn has more tendency to be oxidized than Ag?
The discussion centers around the meanings of the terms "to oxidize" and "to be oxidized," particularly in the context of comparing the tendencies of different metals, such as zinc (Zn) and silver (Ag), to undergo oxidation or reduction. Participants explore the implications of these terms in chemical reactions and reference concepts such as activity series and standard electrode potentials.
Participants express disagreement regarding the definitions and implications of oxidation and reduction, particularly in the context of specific metals. Multiple competing views remain on the tendencies of metals to oxidize or be oxidized, and the discussion does not reach a consensus.
Participants reference standard electrode potentials and activity series, but there are unresolved assumptions about the definitions of oxidation and reduction, as well as the conditions under which these reactions occur.
BaO said:for example: Zn has more tendency to oxidize than Ag, orZn has more tendency to be oxidized than Ag?
That is wrong! Can you directly quote the passage/sentence where it says this?BaO said:wait! how come my book says Zn has more tendency to oxidize than Ag?
Actually, this is not what a reduction potential table tells you. And in fact, Ag will not oxidize Zn (nor will Zn oxidize Ag). If you mix Ag and Zn, there will be no real chemical reaction at all; they will most likely form a nearly isomorphous alloy.sdekivit said:for the serie of metals in oxidation and reduction, a more nobler metal will always oxidize a less nobler metal.
--> thus Ag will oxidize Zn (you can also look this up in a table of standard electrode potentials)
Gokul43201 said:Actually, this is not what a reduction potential table tells you. And in fact, Ag will not oxidize Zn (nor will Zn oxidize Ag). If you mix Ag and Zn, there will be no real chemical reaction at all; they will most likely form a nearly isomorphous alloy.
However, Ag+ will oxidize Zn, while Zn2+ will not oxidize Ag.
Gokul43201 said:Actually, this is not what a reduction potential table tells you. And in fact, Ag will not oxidize Zn (nor will Zn oxidize Ag). If you mix Ag and Zn, there will be no real chemical reaction at all; they will most likely form a nearly isomorphous alloy.
However, Ag+ will oxidize Zn, while Zn2+ will not oxidize Ag.
BaO said:how about this sentence , is it right?
magnesium has a higher tendency to oxidize than does iron?